Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
AAP
AAP
Sport
Steve Larkin, Murray Wenzel, Shayne Hope and Roger Vaughan

REVEALED: It s a firestorm saints coach on tribunal furore | Rare Historical Photos

Zak Butters will front the AFL Appeals Board after he was found guilty of abusing an umpire. (Matt Turner/AAP PHOTOS)

Port Adelaide are demanding an overhaul of the AFL Tribunal system in the wake of Zak Butters' case which has been labelled a "debacle".

The Power remain incensed Butters' testimony was rejected by the tribunal in the controversial case which sparked what St Kilda coach Ross Lyon described as "a firestorm".

"The tribunal process needs to be reformed," Port's chief executive officer Matthew Richardson told reporters on Thursday.

"It's too legalistic, it's too adversarial and it places people under a level of scrutiny and stress that is disproportionate to the nature of the incidents that it's designed to resolve.

"We'll find the solution but let's use this as the moment to do that."

Port and Butters will front the AFL Appeals Board on Monday after the tribunal found the star midfielder guilty of abusing umpire Nick Foot in a Sunday night game. He was fined $1500.

Richardson sidestepped whether his club would be comfortable with Foot umpiring future games involving Port and Butters.

"I don't really want to talk about the individual," he said.

"On the whole, all of those people do an incredible job ... as an industry, as a game, we can do better for them, not put them into these situations."

Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell described the Butters case as a "debacle".

"There are much better ways we could have handled this ... it has been really messy; no-one's winning out of this battle," he told reporters in Melbourne.

Collard
St Kilda's Lance Collard has been banned by the tribunal a second time for using a homophobic slur. (Matt Turner/AAP PHOTOS)

And Saints coach Lyon signalled an appeal to Lance Collard's seven week suspension for making a homophobic comment to an opponent.

In both the Collard and Butters cases, the tribunal rejected evidence from the players who denied making the offensive remarks.

"It's a firestorm and the AFL is in the middle of it and the processes are in the middle of it," Lyon told reporters in Adelaide.

"All of us from club-land are concerned about our individual players and the stress that they're put through and potential damage to that individual - whether it's Butters or Collard or the people being caught up on the other side of the fence."

Asked if the Saints would appeal Collard's suspension - his second ban for using a homophobic slur - Lyon replied: "Clearly, we'll take it as far as we can. What that looks like, I don't know."

Lyon
St Kilda coach Ross Lyon says the separate tribunal verdicts have created a "firestorm" in the AFL. (Con Chronis/AAP PHOTOS)

St Kilda have until Saturday to lodge an appeal against the Collard sanction, which was announced on Tuesday - the same day as Butters' tribunal hearing.

Port believe Butters was branded a liar by the tribunal, which found it was "implausible that Mr Foot would invent the offending comment".

Foot told the tribunal: "The comment that Butters made to me was 'how much are they paying you?' It questioned my integrity."

Butters vehemently denied making that comment.

Brisbane coach Chris Fagan echoed other coaches in querying how the tribunal reached its decision.

Fagan
Brisbane coach Chris Fagan is also querying how the tribunal reached a verdict in the Butters case. (Darren England/AAP PHOTOS)

"Both (Foot and Butters) think they're right. I don't know how you decide when there's no conclusive evidence ... that didn't seem to make any sense to me," Fagan told reporters in Brisbane.

Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge urged "common sense".

"We have got to protect the umpires but the players also need support as well," he told reporters in Melbourne.

"I don't know how that can happen in this situation."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.