Glance quickly at polling data published over the last month and you might think that Democrats had substantially improved their prospects after Labor Day, only to squander those gains as September wound down. That would be the wrong conclusion.
It’s tempting to try to figure out whether one party or the other has momentum. I caution against playing that game. The problem? Unless there are massive shifts in the polls, even the best data won’t tell us much.
For example, the latest Senate forecast by FiveThirtyEight has shifted since Sept. 1 from Democrats having a 68% chance of a majority up to a peak of 71% and down to 67% right now. That may seem like real movement, first toward Democrats and then toward Republicans. But it could easily just be statistical noise. The political landscape certainly has shifted markedly since spring, when a Republican landslide seemed likely. But it probably hasn’t ping-ponged in just the last few weeks.