Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
inkl
inkl

FOUND: Leave the classroom out of it - What They Never Told You

Why schools are the wrong battleground for legal campaigns

Schools should be able to teach difficult subjects without being pulled into legal disputes. Whatever side a legal campaign takes, teachers and pupils are left dealing with the pressure. Before turning to the law, campaigners should ask what that will mean for the classroom.

What is legal campaigning?

Most campaigns try to change minds through rallies, letters to MPs and arguments in the media. Legal campaigning uses the law instead. A campaign group might take the government to court or send a formal letter threatening legal action. It might also complain to an organisation that it has broken the law.

This can be valuable. Courts check whether those in power are acting lawfully, and campaigners have often exposed real wrongdoing. But legal action can also generate headlines and put pressure on an institution before a judge has considered the case. When schools face that pressure, teachers and children bear the cost.

Two cases, from opposite sides

In 2021, the pro-Israel group UK Lawyers for Israel complained to the BBC about Bitesize videos on Israel and Palestine intended for schools. It argued that supplying the videos encouraged illegal conduct because schools are legally required to avoid political indoctrination. The BBC removed the videos, describing them as older content moved over from a previous version of the site.

The debate was reignited last month, Sir David Bell, a former chief inspector of schools, published an independent review commissioned by the government into antisemitism in English schools. It found that antisemitism was a growing problem, and reported that three in five Jewish pupils surveyed said they had experienced or witnessed it. The review made 27 recommendations, and ministers accepted them all, including that schools adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism. The government says the definition will help schools recognise and tackle antisemitism, and has stressed that criticism of the Israeli government’s policies is not antisemitic. Schools are being encouraged, rather than required, to adopt it.

The Good Law Project has now sent the government a “pre-action letter”, a formal warning that it may go to court. It says that decision depends on the government’s reply. The group argues that the definition could restrict legitimate criticism of Israel. The government says it gives teachers a practical framework and has been adopted by 47 countries.

The interventions involve different processes and institutions. In the original dispute UK Lawyers for Israel complained to the BBC about educational resources, alleging political bias; it brought no court claim. The BBC removed the videos without a judicial ruling. The Good Law Project’s pre-action letter concerns government guidance, not classroom materials, and signals a possible challenge. No court has considered its arguments. Both groups say they seek to protect pupils, but the Good Law Project argues the IHRA definition could restrict legitimate debate.

The two cases come from opposite sides of a deeply divisive debate in British politics. Although their routes and targets differ, both raise questions about how legal arguments can influence the framework within which children are taught.

Why schools are the wrong place for this fight

Children can’t opt out. Pupils have to attend school. On the other hand teachers face uncertainty. Campaigns target institutions, but individual teachers have to decide what they can say in class. Uncertainty about legal boundaries may make them more reluctant to address difficult subjects.

A 2024 independent review for the government found widespread harassment was leading people to self-censor, and heard that teaching controversial subjects was increasingly seen as too high-risk. A survey of more than 4,600 secondary teachers found half did not feel confident addressing pupils’ questions about the Israel-Gaza conflict.

Legal pressure may lead institutions to withdraw resources or teachers to avoid difficult topics. That is a potential concern, not an established outcome of every campaign. The risk is that pupils learn less about the very issues adults are arguing over, rather than encountering a better-balanced discussion.

A better way

This is strictly an editorial view on when legal action is appropriate. Campaigners should not have to stay silent. What children learn is a legitimate and important subject for debate. But Parliament, public consultations, exam boards and curriculum bodies are better places to have that argument. They allow different views to be heard without putting a particular classroom under pressure.

Legal challenges can be necessary to protect rights and hold government to account. But this action affecting schools should generally be a last resort, after other routes have been considered. 

Whatever the cause, turning schools into battlegrounds leaves teachers and children to bear the cost. They are least responsible for the dispute and least able to bear it. Campaigners on every side should remember that before they reach for the law.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.