
A good spy series is hard to find. Long-form can be a great platform for the mystery, intrigue, and twists inherent in the genre — but it’s not a catch-all for a weak story. Throwing in a supernatural element also has the capacity to make or break, as the next chapter in AMC’s Immortal Universe, Talamasca: The Secret Order, dolefully demonstrates.
Talamasca is based loosely on the work of Anne Rice, whose Interview with the Vampire has already been adapted (and to great success) by AMC. After two seasons of intimate storytelling, Talamasca is set to kick the door to the Immortal universe wide open: where Interview only teased the inner workings of vampires, witches, and other creatures of the night, its spinoff had the freedom to explore it all with gusto. But Talamasca doesn’t open the floodgates so much as it tiptoes into the wider world of Anne Rice. It’s a much subtler, slower show than Interview, perhaps because it focuses more on the humans of its secret society than the unbridled theatrics of a centuries-spanning vampire love affair. That’s not inherently damning — if AMC is really serious about expanding this franchise, it needs a variety of stories from multiple perspectives. The problem is that the perspectives featured in Talamasca aren’t compelling enough to justify its existence.