Creativity is one of the most important qualities a designer can have. Knowing when to dial it back is a close second. Because as strange as it sounds, design can absolutely suffer from too much imagination.
To show you what we mean, we went over to the subreddit r/DesignDesign, where people share the most hilariously impractical creations on the internet. The pieces we found are all undeniably inventive, but actually using any of them is a completely different story. Scroll down and see for yourself.
This post may include affiliate links.
This Bench Looking Like A Book
This Is Probably The Funniest And Weirdest Washroom Sign
1960 Bmw Isetta
We interact with design every single day, whether we realize it or not. Everything around us was created by someone with a specific purpose in mind. From the chairs we sit on to the apps we use on our phones, all of it went through some kind of design process at some point.
The thing is, that process doesn’t always lead to great results. Sometimes things come out looking a bit off, and sometimes they end up so over-the-top that they become completely unusable.
Cat Spotlight
Oh hell no, i'm not making it easier for my cat to steal my dinner, she manages well enough as it is.
Panthermobile
Three Must Be A Reason Design People Are So Obsessed With Stairs
This is pretty cool. Not great for people who aren't great at climbing stairs, but it's an interesting use of space.
If you’re not a designer, it can be tough to explain exactly why something feels wrong. You might look at a poster on the street and be able to read everything on it, but something about it still bugs you. You know it doesn’t look right, you just can’t quite put your finger on the problem.
Well, there are actually specific principles that separate good design from bad. Robin Williams breaks down four of them in his book “The Non-Designer’s Design Book,” and they’re surprisingly easy to understand. Once you learn what they are, you start noticing them pretty much everywhere.
This Bread Knife In A Swiss Restaurant Has A Silhouette Of The Major Peaks In Switzerland
The Look Of This Office Building
Local Burger Place’s Graphic Menu
The first one is called proximity. The idea is simple: things that belong together should be placed near each other. When related items are grouped closely, they naturally form a visual unit, which makes everything easier to process.
Think about a restaurant menu where all the information is scattered around the page with no clear grouping. Your eyes would jump all over trying to figure out what goes with what. When everything is grouped properly, you can scan through it without any confusion at all.
These Corner Windows
This Whisky Glass
This Wavy Sidewalk Is More Fun And Less Practical
Mmm. One practical purpose might be to slow down any cyclists who choose to get in the way of pedestrians... (I ride pedal and petrol powered bikes, but I like to think I do so without being antisocial about it in either case)
The next principle is alignment. Nothing on a page should feel like it was placed there randomly. Every element needs some kind of visual connection to the things around it. When items are properly aligned, even if they’re far apart, there’s an invisible line that ties them together and creates structure.
You’ve probably seen flyers or websites where the text and images seem to just be floating with no order at all. When everything lines up with intention, the whole piece instantly feels more put together.
Sets
Seat
Creature Cups
Then there’s repetition. This one means using the same visual elements consistently throughout a piece, like the same colors and fonts. It creates unity and makes everything feel like it belongs to the same family.
Imagine walking through a building where every floor has completely different signage with its own fonts and color scheme. It would feel messy and disorienting. Consistent signage throughout the whole building makes navigation easy and gives the place a much more professional feel. It also tells people that the design was done with care and thought.
Having To Scan A Qr Code In Case Of Emergency
Coffee Table With Bonus Mountain Range
Cliff Cup
The last one is contrast. If two elements are supposed to be different from each other, they should be very different. Contrast is often what grabs your attention first and makes you actually want to look at something. It also helps organize information by making it clear what matters most.
Think about a remote control where every single button is the same size and color. You’d have to read the tiny label on each one just to find the volume. When the important buttons are bigger or a different color, you can find what you need instantly without even thinking about it.
This Speedometer
Would limit everyone to 93kmh (~ 60mph), which is the cheetah's maximum speed. Wouldn't be so bad.
Gosh
Sunglasses, Mask, Face Shield
When you look at the over-designed creations in this list, you’ll probably notice that many of them break several of these principles at once. Sometimes the elements are spread so far apart that proximity goes completely out the window. Other times, alignment is all over the place, or there’s so much going on that nothing creates real contrast anymore.
Many of these pieces are undeniably creative on a technical level. The problem is that creativity without solid principles behind it tends to produce something that looks impressive at first glance but falls apart when you actually try to use it.
Man Ray Chess Set (1926)
Queen and King look too similar. Need a cross atop the king at least.
Sweater That’s Also A Backpack
So, if it's cold enough to need a sweater, you have to take off your sweater and be cold to access the backpack part. I also bet this thing quickly stretches out of shape.
The Pi Bike Or Picycle
Either you were born to fit this bike or you can't ride it. Not adjustable. Should be in a gallery or museum.
These four principles are far from the only ones out there. There are plenty of other guidelines and rules that go into truly good design. But proximity, alignment, repetition, and contrast give you a solid starting point for understanding why something works or why it doesn’t.
So next time you come across something that makes you tilt your head and wonder what went wrong, you’ll have a much better idea of what to look for.
This Handrail
Chairs In Despair
The seat on the left end is unusable unless you are a child or a very tall NBA basketball player. Regular people have knees that need to bend well before that seat allows.
Dangling A Toilet Above Another Toilet
Bike Rack Looks Fallen Over And Only Useable On One Side
It allows you to lock your bike in a few crucial spots, which can be useful in places where they steal your seat and wheels.
What Is Even The Goal Of The Photographer Here?
Create A Problem, Solve The Problem, Profit!
LED Sign I Came Across On Amazon Today. :-D Seeyouspa Cecowboy
This Teapot Is Very
Tp. Tpeach. Teace Peach
This Is Supposed To Be A Bathtub
This Is What Happens When You Let An Architect With Too Much Free Time Loose
Glass Sink In A Hotel
I have a plain rectangular sink. It is a horrible design--I have to clean it every time I use it. Bring back round and oval sinks!
The Entire Hotel Room Lights Up When Someone Turns On The Bathroom Light
Salt Lake City, Triple Decker Fireplace
Open / Closed Door Sign
Okay - so, 'apparently meaningless squiggle' either way round. Having been told that the sign says 'open' and 'closed', I can figure out how it's supposed to read that way, but it's not remotely clear.
Because People Love Sitting On Bike Seats When They Don’t Have To
Bike Rack That Prioritizes Form Over Function
This Bed Was Designed To Wreck My Shins At Night
A Perfectly Designed Balcony
Traditional Ceramic Motifs Reimagined
The Cup I Got At A Restaurant, Yes That Is Supposed To Be The Handle, Even The Waiter Was Struggling To Hold It
But don't we all love the challenge of holding scalding hot liquid in a hard-to-grip vessel? /sarc
This Hotel Bathroom Art Is A Little Xcessive With The Expressiv
Rip White Shirts
Handrail With Gaps And Sharp Edges
A Sink That... Sinks?
This Keyboard With Blurry Keycaps Made To Look Like Early 3D Video Game Graphics
What In The World Is This Supposed To Say?
It's Got Design In The Name!
The "Anti-Diver": A Design Rejected By Both Watch Purists And Professional Designers. Form Follows Vibe
A Watch That Doesn't Tell Time, Minimal Dial Design For Mindfulness Lovers
About as useful as the three watches I do own. They all have d**d batteries since I got a cellphone that I always carry with me. I have three expensive bracelets now.
An Ad Inside The Gym To Get Coaching And Structure
"If this is all you do, most of the gym you're missing." Written by Yoda it was!
Who The Heck Invented This? The Most Uncomfortable Toilet I Ever Sat On And It Was A Luxury Hotel
It Looks Cool But Isn't Great To Use
Tape dispenser. Tape is rotated to make it difficult to get the tape to feed without binding.
Meatball Plate By Gustav Westman X IKEA
Single-Color Chess
This list is just silly. It mixes bad, gimmicky and obviously faulty design with renowned classics of good design. Obviously compiled by someone who knows nothing about the subject.
This list is just silly. It mixes bad, gimmicky and obviously faulty design with renowned classics of good design. Obviously compiled by someone who knows nothing about the subject.
