Bored Panda
50 Times People Found Something So Ridiculous At The Thrift Store They Just Had To Share
CuriositiesJUN 25, 2025

BIZARRE: Thrift grift scams | Mind Blowing Facts

61
26
Shopping at thrift stores is great: you can find something authentic, it doesn't hurt your wallet, and you're helping the planet by not contributing to overconsumption. In 2024, roughly 90% of Americans and Canadians engaged with a thrift store through either shopping or donating. And Gen Z is leading the trend, with 60% thrifting monthly.
Nevertheless, lately, thrifting lovers have noticed a worrying trend where second-hand goods are often pricier than their new counterparts. So much so that they've been posting the prices online and shaming thrift retailers. We've collected the funniest and most absurd examples of ridiculous thrift item prices and will present them to you here, Pandas!

#1 Cocktail Umbrellas $12 Each

Hand holding two miniature foldout fans with price tags, a ridiculous thrift store find shared online.
Seen in an antique store, so possibly vintage? Still this is one of the most ridiculous things I've seen in a second hand shop. And the pink one was ripped! Saw a listing on eBay where you could buy 25 vintage ones for $20. And new you can get about 145 for $9 from Oriental Trading Company.
63points

#2 I Just Get Mad When I Go Now

Furniture ticket showing a $6000 price for a vintage Afghan rug and another ticket on an inexpensive table at a thrift store.
Some little Mexican lady that spoke little English came up to me while in goodwill and said, “I no afford anything, this donation yes?” Made me so sick, these prices are ridiculous.
51points

#3 The Goodwill Price Is Almost Double Of The Marshall’s It’s Came From

Price tag comparison on thrift store men's long sleeve shirt showing two different prices on one item.
49points

Back in the day, shopping second-hand was mostly for those who couldn't afford pricier clothes or were looking for one-of-a-kind items. Nowadays, thrifting has become a trend. According to a 2025 report by Capital One Shopping Centre, roughly 30% of all apparel bought in the U.S. was second-hand.

The folks who shared the items we see on this list aren't the only ones who noticed that thrifting isn't like it used to be. Experts estimate that the second-hand goods market can be valued at somewhere between $100 and $120 billion worldwide. So, if it's so profitable, why is a single roll of toilet paper over $1 at 'Goodwill'? Or is it so profitable because of the jacked-up prices?

#4 Is This A Joke?

Hand holding a black hair tie with a $2.99 price tag found at the thrift store, showing a ridiculous thrift store find.
47points

#5 I Thought These Were Free On The USPS Website. This Local Goodwill Is Breaking The Law I Think. Do I Report Them To Their Corporate Or USPS?

Stack of large flat rate USPS priority mail boxes wrapped in plastic at a thrift store with price stickers visible
47points

#6 Stitch Marker "Earrings"

Hand holding thrift store price tag showing $2.99 for colorful plastic costume jewelry at Savers thrift store.
Found these "earrings" at the local Savers. Tried to tell a cashier that they weren't earrings and are available like 50pc for $3 she said, "well some kid will probably wear them as earrings because they look like safety pins."
They are... Not traditional ear piercing size.
47points

One of the reasons second-hand items are more expensive nowadays is because of rising demand. People (especially younger ones) are more eco-conscious than ever and choose to shop sustainably. In fact, 67% of American consumers say that sustainability is a priority when shopping.

It's basic economics: when the demand for something increases, retailers tend to up their price—even if they're second-hand goods. What's more, many thrift stores have become aware of the real value of some of their items. That's especially true for consignment stores—second-hand shops where retailers sell items on behalf of their owners.

#7 My Local Thrift Shop Got A New Store Manager

Ridiculously overpriced thrift store silverware sets with price tags over two hundred dollars each wrapped in plastic.
45points

#8 No Authenticity, No Certification, No Return, No Exchange, No Explanation

Gold necklace with a $2,399.99 price tag displayed in a thrift store, highlighting ridiculous thrift store finds shared online.
Report
45points

#9 I Think The Employees Just Do This To See If Someone Actually Buys It

Ridiculous thrift store find showing paper towels and toilet paper with price tags on a shelf surrounded by mugs and dishes.
45points

Thrifting expert and consignment store lover Jessie Frances of Cappuccinos & Consignment notes that some thrift stores began curating their selection in response to this growing demand. They're offering more items that may be of higher quality and made by famous brands. 

Many thrift stores would have designer bags, clothes, and accessories put behind glass in the past. But nowadays, there are smaller, more unique thrift stores offering only this kind of second-hand selection.

#10 I'll Style This With My Versachi And Goochie

Close-up of a thrift store clothing tag on a Burberry shirt priced at 49.99, showing size and men's long sleeve dress style.
43points

#11 I Gave Up Today When I Found This KFC Container For 0.89 Today

Plastic KFC bucket lid found at thrift store, showcasing a unique and ridiculous thrift store find idea.
43points

#12 There Has To Be Something I'm Missing Here. Is There Something To This Rock?

Hand holding a large rock with a $24.99 Goodwill price tag, a ridiculous thrift store find shared online.
43points

As thrifting has been gaining popularity, more stores are opening and more people are working in the stores themselves, but also at donation centers and even in logistics. Consider how big most thrift stores are and just think about how much they're paying for rent. This, together with wages, utilities, and logistical costs, really adds to the bottom line many thrift stores have to cover.

#13 Dude

Waffle iron with burnt, moldy waffle inside found at thrift store, showcasing ridiculous thrift store finds.
Report
42points

#14 Hm. Charity Diapers Meant To Be Free For Needy Families. “Not For Sale” On Sale At Griftwill

Package of diapers with thrift store price tag showing $3.99 on a shelf in a thrift store setting.
41points

Second-hand online shopping has really taken off since the pandemic, too. Platforms like Vinted, ThredUp, Poshmark, and Depop have become serious competitors to giants like the Salvation Army and Goodwill. Aside from the convenience (you can just log in and browse while having lunch or lulling yourself to sleep), many online sellers also offer lower prices, making physical stores less attractive.

#15 How Did These Make It Out To The Shelf?

Worn out cracked shoes found at the thrift store shelf, showcasing ridiculous thrift store finds shared by shoppers.
Report
41points

#16 At "Value" Village In Canada

Bright pink flip flops with a $29.99 thrift store price tag displayed on a metal shelf at a thrift store sale.
Report
41points

#17 $800 For “Some Gold Earring Singles And Cool Beads” Says The Employee

Glass jar filled with assorted thrift store jewelry pieces priced ridiculously high at 799.99 dollars.
40points

#18 Oh The Possibilities

Hand holding an empty cardboard tube with a $1 price tag found at a thrift store among miscellaneous items.
40points

There's also a serious downside to thrifting becoming so popular. People are noticing how it's becoming a form of fast fashion in itself. If you're a frequent thrifter, you may have seen items from Shein, Temu, and other fast fashion brands making the rounds at your favorite thrift shop.

According to Fashion Innovation, "The glorification of thrifting as the new and hip sustainable fashion trend encourages shopping addictions and overconsumption, which in turn contribute to similar issues we are trying to combat."

#19 $5 For A Blown Out Hole And A Spider

Spider crawling on a ripped thrift store shirt, highlighting ridiculous finds people shared from thrift store shopping.
40points

#20 I Love Reducing Waste, But Not Everything Needs To Be Donated To The Thrift Store. There's No Way Those Markers Aren't Dry, Right?

Thrift store art set found with only a few markers and pencils, missing most of the original 68 pieces inside the plastic case.
39points
61
26