Bored Panda
55 Missing Person Cases That Took Absolutely Bizarre Turns

EXPLAINED: Missing person cases fell like horror stories | Vintage Vibes

34
6
One moment they're there. The next, they've vanished. Hundreds of thousands of people go missing in the United States every year. Sometimes, it's a case of the person deliberately disappearing but other times, there's something a lot more sinister at play.
Take Nancy Guthrie, for example. The mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie is believed to have been snatched from her bed in the middle of the night. Months later, her whereabouts are still unknown, and no arrests have yet been made. The mystery proves that none of us are ever 100% safe, even in our own homes. Someone asked, "What missing person case in America feels like a straight-up internet horror story?" and many of the responses read like the stuff nightmares are made of.
Bored Panda has put together a list of some of the most bone-chilling ones. There's the story of the woman who got abducted from a payphone booth while on a call with her fiancé, the 9-year-old girl who walked out of her house at 3am during a thunderstorm, and plenty of others that might have you sleeping with one eye open.

#1

A pig on a farm, a seemingly unrelated image to symbolize the chilling randomness of missing person cases.
Not America but Canada. All of the missing women whose remains were found at the Pickton pig farm. That story is the most disturbing thing to happen in my area.
26points

More than 500,000 people go missing every year in the United States alone. That's according to data from the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs), a resource center for missing, unidentified, and unclaimed person cases across the country.

NamUs' site notes that between 2021 and 2025, an average of 532,727 missing persons records annually were entered into the National Crime Information Center. It adds that many individuals reported missing are found alive and well, but some become long-term missing persons. Then there are those found deceased but unidentified.

"Over 11,000 sets of unidentified human remains were held in medical examiner and coroner offices throughout the U.S. according to the 2018 Census of Medical Examiners and Coroners," reveals NamUS. It's a scary statistic.

#2

A young woman sitting in a car, looking out, illustrating the feeling of being vulnerable in missing person cases.
Martha Leanne Green - she was picked up by her twin brother from work, but they run out of gas just a half mile up the road. A nice family pulls over and offers to take them to get gas. Her brother goes with them, but she decides to stay in the locked car and wait for him to return. In the nine minutes it took to get gas and return to the car, she vanished.
23points

#3

A building with a large SCIENTOLOGY sign, linked to high-profile missing person cases.
Shelley Miscavige

The whole scientology thing is weird but this is peak weird.
23points

According to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, nearly 30,000 children were reported missing in 2024 alone.

The Federal Investigation Bureau (FBI) says that about 90% of those cases were resolved, adding that a vast majority of missing children cases turn out to be runaways. Despite this, investigators are trained to treat each case as a missing minor and possible abduction until they learn otherwise.

#4

This is a Canadian one but Amber Tuccaro, she was a first Nations woman who was kidnapped when she was hitchhiking a ride from Edmonton. 

She was on a call with I believe her cousin(?) and you can hear she starts realizing the man is taking her from where she was wanting to go, she starts asking him where he's taking her and he tries lying to her then the call gets dropped. That's the last anyone has heard or seen of her, and people believe she was a victim to an active serial criminal that's been preying on women from Edmonton.
23points

#5

A forest path representing a location connected to missing person cases that still terrify people years later.
Asha Degree.

9 year old girl walks out of her house around 3am with a backpack and just starts walking down the road in a thunderstorm. Multiple cars pass her, but when a motorist tries to help, she runs into the woods. Never seen again.

Investigators find some of her belongings the next day, but no leads. A year and a half after she disappears, her backpack is found wrapped in trash bags and buried at a construction site.

No new leads until 2024 when some new search warrants were issued. Still no trace of her.
22points

#6

Three kayaks on a riverbank, hinting at a water-related missing person case investigation.
Nancy Ng. 

She's the same age as me and from my hometown. She went on a yoga retreat with a bunch of people in Guatemala. The group rented kayaks and went out on a lake. Everyone returned on their kayaks except her, and immediately flew home. All of them are refusing to speak on the matter.
22points

Children go missing for various reasons. Some are taken by a person known to them, such as a parent, other relative, or family friend. Others run away to meet an online acquaintance or to escape their home life. Then there are those reported as missing in order to cover up horrific crimes.

Some children, especially babies, are kidnapped by people who want to raise them as their own. There are also cases of very young kids, or those with developmental disabilities, wandering off and getting lost. And there are children who get snatched by complete strangers.

#7

An old green payphone in the dark, symbolizing a mysterious communication point in missing person cases.
Angela Hammond. I saw this case as a kid on Unsolved Mysteries and never forgot it.

In 1991, she was abducted from a payphone booth while on the phone with her boyfriend. He heard her screaming and also heard the voice of the person who is presumed to have kidnapped her.

So her boyfriend hops in his car and starts racing toward where she is. At some point on that route, a truck passes by headed the opposite direction and he hears her screaming from the truck. He attempts to turn around to chase the truck, but his car breaks down. She's never been found.
17points

#8

A young man in a red and white shirt, representing a missing person case that still terrifies people years later.
Jason Jolkowski. He left his home in broad daylight to go meet his friend a few blocks away but never showed up and was never seen again. There has literally never been a trace of him found between the few blocks he was supposed to walk that day. No camera footage, no clothing, no witnesses. He just walked out of his house and was never seen or heard from again.
17points

#9

Black and white portrait of a smiling woman, a missing person from a cold case.
Jodi Huisentruit

Jodi was a news anchor in 1995. On the day of her disappearance, a coworker called Jodi at 4 AM when they noticed that Jodi was late for work. Jodi answered the call and said she had overslept, but was on her way. She never showed up. When police were called, they found signs of a struggle outside her apartment near her car including a bent car key and her shoes, leading them to believe she had been abducted.

It’s been over 30 years, and she’s never been seen or found. It’s still an active investigation.
17points

The FBI's Child Abduction Rapid Deployment (CARD) Team steps in when a child is believed to have been abducted by a stranger. They're ready to deploy at a moment's notice.

"Rapid is part of the team's name for a reason," reads the FBI's site. "When a child is missing, time is a central factor."

There are number of reasons why... Based on past cases, as well as interviews with victims and perpetrators, the FBI warns that children abducted by for the purpose of a*****t are usually harmed within minutes of the abduction.

#10

It's always going to be Shannon Sherrill for me. A little girl out playing hid and seek with neighborhood kids and she just vanished. I don't buy the serial k**ler story. I think something far worse happened to her.
17points

#11

A white car at night, possibly linked to missing person cases, with its taillight glowing red in the dark.
Jennifer Kesse. Someone was caught on video parking her car about a mile away from her apartment the day she went missing but because of the poor quality, their face is blocked by fencing in every single frame. Super creepy that this person was recorded the day of the incident but they got so lucky and have still never been identified.
16points

#12

An overflowing dumpster with cardboard boxes and a cat resting nearby, evoking urban missing person cases.
Diana Vicari

Just learned about her story, basically she vanished one night and they found only her arms in a dumpster, still unsolved.
16points

"Time is also critical in recovering the abducted child alive," says Special Agent Jenifer Sparks, who leads the FBI's South Central CARD Team. Sparks reveals that historically, in cases where children are abducted and not found alive, 74% pass away within three hours of being taken. 90% don't make it to 24 hours.

Thankfully, the FBI says child abductions by complete strangers are rare. "In roughly 19 years, the CARD Team has deployed for 225 child abductions, an average of 12 a year," notes the agency.

#13

Brian Shaffer. Walking into a bar with only one exit and completely vanishing from security footage.
16points

#14

Stack of newspapers representing old missing person cases and news archives.
Combo of three:

* Johnny Gosch, 12 years old, disappeared while delivering the Des Moines Register on September 5, 1982 at
42nd Street & Marcourt Lane, West Des Moines, Iowa, U.S.

* Eugene Martin, 13 years old, disappeared while delivering the Des Moines Register on August 12, 1984 at
Southwest 12th Street & Highview Drive, Des Moines, Iowa, U.S.

* Marc Allen, 13 years old, disappeared while going to visit his friend on March 29, 1986 at Emma Ave, Des Moines, Iowa, U.S.

Overall distance, 13 miles, and a 23 minute drive between each. Gosch disappeared exactly a 4 minute drive away from the Interstate 80 and Interstate 35 interchange. While Martin & Allen disappeared just a short mile away from each other.
14points

#15

A line of young children with backpacks, walking together, reminding of vulnerability in missing person cases.
Kyron Horman. 2010. 7 years old and disappeared from his elementary school in Portland. His disappearance launched the largest criminal investigation in Portland's history. Lots of theories around his step-mom, Terry.
14points

If your child ever (God forbid) goes missing, you should call your local law enforcement agency immediately.

Provide them with your child’s name, date of birth, height, weight, and descriptions of any other unique identifiers such as eyeglasses, braces or scars. Explain when you noticed your child was missing, what clothing they were wearing, and any other important details that could help with the search.

"Request law enforcement authorities immediately enter your child’s name and identifying information into the FBI’s National society/">Crime Information Center Missing Person File," adds the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children's site.

#16

A police wristband and evidence marker number 1 on the ground, suggesting investigation of missing person cases.
DeOrr Kunz Jr. ‘is a 2-year-old boy who vanished on July 10, 2015, from the remote Timber Creek Campground in Lemhi County, Idaho. Despite a decade of extensive searches and investigations by authorities, the case remains open and unsolved with no trace of the child ever found’

Being a parent of a 2 year old right now, I can’t even begin to imagine what that child went through. How scared he must of been. I hope the case is solved in my life time.
13points

#17

Andrew Gosden. UK 2007. He faked off from school and bought himself a one way train ticket to London. Where he was last seen exiting King Cross Station never to be seen again.
13points

#18

The Springfield Three. Suzie Streeter and Stacy McCall were friends and had just graduated high school in Springfield, Missouri. They were staying at Suzie’s house, and when a third friend showed up the next day for a planned meetup, everyone was gone, including Suzie’s mother, Sherrill Levitt. All of their belongings were still in the house, including purses, clothes, cigarettes, etc. Outside of a broken porch light, nothing was out of place and there were no signs of a struggle. Suzie, Stacy, and Sherrill have not been seen or heard from since.
Report
12points

If you're in the United States, once you have called the police, you can also call the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at 1-800-THE-LOST® (1-800-843-5678).

If your child goes missing at home, experts at that center advise that you search through closets, piles of laundry, in and under beds, inside large appliances, inside vehicles (including trunks) and anywhere else that a child may be able to crawl or hide.

If your child goes missing in a mall or in a store, notify the store manager or security office. Then immediately call your local law enforcement agency. "Many stores have a Code Adam plan of action in place," reveals the center.

#19

A lone figure walks down a dark, narrow alley illuminated by a single streetlamp, hinting at mysterious missing person cases.
Lindsey Baum. Kidnapped from McCleary, WA 16 years ago while walking home from a friend’s house. Super small sleepy town, so it truly shocked the community. My family was on the way home from the coast after it happened and police were stopping and searching all cars, so it’s stuck with me for years. They found partial remains in Eastern WA, but no one’s ever been convicted. Hoping her family gets closure one day.
11points

#20

Yuba County Five has always been a complete horror story in my mind. All those crazy things about them just dying by a roadside and the one guy who went into a shed and lived for months without eating, despite there being food.
11points
34
6