Bored Panda
50 Times Readers Forgot To Take Their Bookmarks Before Giving Away Their Books
CuriositiesMAR 8, 2025

THE TRUTH ABOUT: Stuff found in books - The Untold Story

101
18
People say that entire worlds can fit inside a book, no matter how tiny it is. Books give us fearless heroes, relatable stories, and transport us to lands unknown. But books can also carry stories as physical conduits: stories of their readers' past.
There's an online community that shares the odd and delightful things readers find inside their old books. The subreddit, aptly titled r/ForgottenBookmarks, is all about the quirky and sometimes strange things people use as bookmarks, forgetting them only for its next reader to find many years later.
Bored Panda reached out to the creator and the moderator of the community, u/unmoderated, and they kindly agreed to give us a little backstory about the subreddit. Read our conversation below!
More info: Reddit

This post may include affiliate links.

#1 Found A Lincoln Campaign Ribbon In An Old Book At An Antique Store!

Vintage bookmark featuring Abraham Lincoln for book lovers.
147points

#2 Found In A Bible From 1895, “Ain’t I A Peach? Ha, Ha”

Vintage bookmarks made from an old photo and handwritten note, discovered by book lovers.
108points

#3 Homemade Bookmark Found In A Library Book: “Was I Ever Happier..”

Handmade bookmark with a nostalgic quote about noodles and snow, featuring simple art.
Report
103points

The story of r/ForgottenBookmarks is quite an interesting one. Created in 2008 by the Redditor u/unmoderated, it was an extension of the blog they started in 2007. "I was the manager at my family's used and rare bookshop and always thought these finds were interesting," u/unmoderated tells Bored Panda.

"I shared a few with friends and decided to just make a simple Blogspot so I wouldn't have to send out emails," they add. Thus, the Forgotten Bookmarks blog was born. Throughout the years, that it was active, the Redditor posted many personal, funny, heartbreaking, and weird things they've found in the old books at their family's store.

#4 Forgotten Bookmarks - Library Edition

Creative bookmarks displayed on a bulletin board, showcasing unique designs for book lovers to enjoy.
101points

#5 Actual (Home-Made) Bookmark I Found In An Antique Book

Colorful bookmark with "Books are friends" on a vintage page.
97points

#6 Found Inside A Copy Of The Sirens Of Titan At The Goodwill Bins

Cat-themed bookmark on a book page, featuring a cat and toy figure.
95points

Although the blog and other social media accounts for Forgotten Bookmarks aren't active anymore, in its heyday, it was quite popular. "The blog and the Twitter account ended up getting some traction and led to two books published by Penguin in 2011 and 2012," the creator tells us.

Indeed, you can even buy the two books today. The first one is a collection of similar things to this list, and it's titled Forgotten Bookmarks: A Bookseller's Collection of Odd Things Lost Between The Pages. The second one is a book of recipes: Handwritten Recipes: A Bookseller's Collection of Curious and Wonderful Recipes Forgotten Between the Pages. 

#7 This "Bookmark" I Found In An Old Shakspeare Book Is A Voting Ticket From The Civil War

Antique bookmark featuring Lincoln campaign details next to an ornate Shakespeare book cover.
Report
92points

#8 Found 20 Million German Mark In A Book From 1923. Time To Retire

Book lovers using a vintage German banknote as a unique bookmark in an open book.
87points

#9 Found In A Book Of Poetry Purchased In Used Bookstore. The Back Of The Photo Has "1 Year Old" And "1999" Written On It. I Hope This Now 25-Year-Old Is A Happy Reader

A smiling baby in a floral outfit, not related to book lovers or bookmarks.
Report
83points

As far as the subreddit goes, u/unmoderated doesn't have much time to partake in making sure things are running smoothly there. "I wish I could take some of the credit for the subreddit, but I'm probably the worst moderator on Reddit," they quip. "I created it many years back to pair with my blog forgottenbookmarks.com and never really spent much time on it."

#10 I Was Told To Post This Here. Found In A Book I Bought

Handwritten love note bookmark on carpet background.
77points

#11 Cool Vintage Bookmark I Found

Book lovers use a vintage Blockbuster card as a unique bookmark between pages.
77points

#12 Found In A Second Hand Birdwatchers Book

A hand holding a book with a unique bird sketch bookmark inside, labeled "Black Capped Chickadee."
76points

Life got in the way for the Redditor to continue posting on the blog and its social media accounts, too. "I took over the bookstore in 2016, and between that and having a young child and then the 2020 stuff, I have more or less stepped away," they clarify. Well, the good news is that r/ForgottenBookmarks seems to be doing quite well on its own, having over 76k members and several new posts daily.

#13 News Article From 1997 Found Inside An Old Religious Book. I Wonder Who Put It There

Newspaper article discussing support for gay kids placed next to books, including a Bible, resembling cool bookmarks.
75points

#14 From A 1955 Copy Of The Idiot By Dostoyevsky

Beautiful bookmark with fish design and intricate border, featuring the words "Love one another." Perfect for book lovers.
73points

#15 Inside A 150 Year Old Book I Found A 4-Leaf Clover Dated June 17, 1923

A vintage book opened with a four-leaf clover bookmark, showcasing a unique find by a book lover.
Report
69points

When we ask u/unmoderated whether forgotten bookmarks sometimes might get put between the book pages on purpose, they're doubtful. "I always go with the assumption that the bookmarks were forgotten. The only items I think might have been left on purpose were leaves and flowers to be pressed," the Redditor says.

#16 1950 Five Dollar Bill In A 1935 Cookbook

Five-dollar bill used as a bookmark in an old baking recipe book, showcasing a creative find by book lovers.
Report
68points

#17 My Favorite Kind Of Bookmark

Handwritten note found in a book, shared by a book lover, reflecting on dreams and personal growth.
64points

#18 Found Someone’s 116 Year Old Travel Itinerary Tucked In An Antique Guidebook To Paris

Handwritten notes used as cool bookmarks beside an open guidebook.
Report
61points

There was one curious object that u/unmoderated still remembers finding in a book to this day. "It was not a forgotten bookmark, but I did find a 'baby book,' one of those little decorative keepsakes where you fill in a baby's height and weight, when they walked for the first time, etc. It was all filled out until the baby was two years old or so, [with] lots of photos inside."

"Keep in mind, the birth date listed was from the 1950s or so, had the full name – but all of my internet sleuthing skills and even a ton of help from Twitter weren't enough to find the person or any family," the Redditor adds.

#19 Tiny Feather In An 1888 Danish Proedikener Ober Evangelierne

Unique bookmark made from a peacock feather held between fingers, showcasing a book lover's creative find.
Report
61points

#20 The Most Random (And Terrifying) Bookmarks Found At My Library Recently

Unique bookmark featuring a smiling person printed on paper, placed on a wooden surface.
Report
51points
101
18