Bored Panda
30 Cooking Myths That People In This Online Thread Wish Others Knew Are False
FoodMAY 8, 2025

FORGOTTEN HISTORY: Useless cooking rules ignore - The Untold Story

51
11
Everyone has to eat, so it probably makes sense, at some point, to learn how to actually cook. In the age of the internet, it’s never been easier, there are literally thousands of recipes, often with videos of how to do things. But, in all that noise, it can be good to pick out what actually works.
Someone asked “What cooking advice doesn't make any difference?” and people detailed their tips, tricks and observations. We also got in touch with the person who posted the question in the first place. So get comfortable as you scroll through, upvote your favorites and be sure to share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.

#1

Two chefs in a kitchen, one peeling a carrot and the other stirring a pot, sharing common cooking advice.
My grandmother insisted and would get angry for people not following her sacred advice...you must always stir clockwise. Tried it counterclockwise and I get the same result Her spirit did reach through the void and smack me though.
76points

#2

Person chopping raw chicken on a wooden board, demonstrating common cooking advice shared by many home cooks.
YOU DON'T NEED TO WASH YOUR CHICKEN. I will literally fight anyone who says you do. I've been cooking for 18 years, cook raw chicken weekly and have NEVER gotten sick. If anything washing chicken creates possible contamination.
74points

#3

Person holding a bowl near butter and a colander in a kitchen setting with common cooking advice items visible
I use salted butter even when it calls for unsalted.
61points

Bored Panda got in touch with the netizen who posted this question online and they were kind enough to share some more details. Naturally, we were curious to hear why they asked this to the internet in the first place. “I'm simply an impatient cook. I don't want to marinade for 20+ hours,” they shared.

“I don't want to wash rice or eat cold steak because “I need to rest it 10 minutes." I use the microwave for steaming vegetables — and it's better than a pan and faster than a pan and fewer dishes than a pan. I'm cheap too. Salt is salt (people really buy fancy salt; it's NaCl — only 2 elements).”

#4

Hands holding uncooked spaghetti over a pot, illustrating common cooking advice in kitchen food preparation.
Using large amounts of water to cook pasta. You can use a much smaller amount AND it's actually better for having more concentrated starchy water for dishes like cacio e pepe.
54points

#5

Hand stirring spaghetti in boiling water with bubbles, illustrating common cooking advice that may not be effective.
Throwing oil in pasta cooking water. Those two don't mix. All you're doing is wasting the oil. It will achieve absolutely nothing. If you're concerned about them sticking and need to use it, use it *after* they're cooking. Stop it.

Edit:if you're concerned about your pots boiling over you could always try paying attention.
49points

#6

30 Cooking Myths That People In This Online Thread Wish Others Knew Are False
Only adding oil to a hot skillet.


i've added oil to a cold skillet and it was fine.
49points

“How many butters do you need in your refrigerator? I watched a cooking show where they insisted on $300 and $500+ pans and Dutch ovens and... And no. A knife should cut food. I'm not spending $150+ on a single knife; a knife I can't even throw in the dishwasher even,” they added.

#7

Person sifting flour through a metal sieve over a wooden surface, demonstrating common cooking advice in a kitchen.
It depends a *lot* on specific recipes. But a couple that jump out at me:

Garlic presses are perfectly acceptable alternatives to mincing garlic with a knife in many applications. Jarred garlic is perfectly acceptable in many applications.

Sifting flour doesn't matter in most recipes (but matters a lot in a few).
41points

#8

Chef seasoning food in a pot on stovetop illustrating common cooking advice that often doesn't improve dishes.
Salt before the water is boiling or after. It changes f**k all, do whatever you want.
36points

#9

Fork holding spaghetti with sauce, illustrating common cooking advice that doesn't really do anything.
I’m going to continue breaking my spaghetti noodles into pieces that are more convenient to boil AND eat and nobody can convince me this is not a superior way of going about things!
30points

We also wanted to hear their opinion on why the thread ended up with thousands of comments and examples from across the internet. “It's popular because cooking is filled with old wives tales. It's popular because we're all a little lazy and tired of pretentious cooking.”

#10

Person using metal tongs to cook bread slices in hot oil on stovetop, illustrating common cooking advice.
Using a screaming hot pan for searing. You can't cook higher than the smoke point of your oil. All you're doing is tripping your home's smoke detectors, creating acrid oxidized fats that's terrible for you and tastes bad.

Maillard reaction only needs around 300-330F. Plenty of room below the smoke point to get a nice sear without breaking down your oil to acrid flavors.
29points

#11

Pot of eggs on stove with water, illustrating common cooking advice and tips that may not be effective.
Boiling eggs in water with a splash of vinegar does *not* make it easier to peel them when they're cooked.
28points

#12

Close-up of fresh mushrooms on a wooden cutting board with a knife and carrots, illustrating common cooking advice.
I grew up hearing that you're not supposed to wash mushrooms but I always do and it turns out fine.
27points

They left us with some parting thoughts. “I'm not a very good cook. I can't seem to get the hang of a meat thermometer for example and to see if a steak is done, I'll cut a small slice into it to check if it hit medium. Then I'll eat my hot steak 3 minutes after I pull it off the grill. And I love my steaks (hence why my brother challenged me to a "who can make the best steak" contest. I'm still bitter that we "tied").”

#13

Person stirring steaming food in a pan on a gas stove cooking in a kitchen following common cooking advice.
I don't heat milk up before adding it to roux.
27points

#14

Bowl of creamy mashed potatoes garnished with chopped chives, illustrating common cooking advice shared by people.
You don't need a ricer to make amazing mashed potatoes.

If you're a broke college student, you can make them with a g*****n *fork*. I wouldn't recommend it, but it can be done.
25points

#15

Hands stretching sticky dough over a floured surface illustrating common cooking advice that doesn’t really work.
Active dry versus instant yeast.

Most bakers and recipe writers say to just chuck the yeast in with the dries. The whole step of putting active dry yeast and warm water to bloom it is just checking the yeast is alive.

If you know you bought it relatively recently don’t bother with that step.
23points

“But I do stand by a quote from Anthony Bourdain, "Garlic is Devine. Anyone too lazy to peel and chop it fresh doesn't deserve to eat it." But I'll agree the garlic press people are probably right in that it doesn't make a difference.”

#16

30 Cooking Myths That People In This Online Thread Wish Others Knew Are False
The whole “always use fresh garlic” thing. Sometimes the jarred stuff hits just fine.
23points

#17

30 Cooking Myths That People In This Online Thread Wish Others Knew Are False
It’s okay if your mushrooms are steaming at first (due to pan overcrowding). Just let them cook down and they’ll get that nice brown color.
22points

#18

Close-up of creamy mashed potatoes in a pot, illustrating common cooking advice shared by many people.
I made mascarpone and cream cheese from scratch the other day. All the recipes on line say to avoid using ultrapasteurized cream but it's very hard to find cream that has not been UP these days. They say it could have the proteins already broken down. Considering that UT brings the cream to 185F for TWO SECONDS and when you make mascarpone or cream cheese you bring the cream to 185 for several minutes i reasoned that someone must have said this once for no good reason and now it's in every recipe. It's wrong! Made great mascarpone and cream cheese.
21points

#19

Pressure cooker on stove with stovetop burner on, illustrating common cooking advice and kitchen techniques.
My husband's British mother used to- get this- PRESSURE COOK the steak first- like, on a steam rack in the pot. Then she'd take it out and sear it. He swears, up down and sideways, that method makes scrumptious steak. I'm nearly 60, and I'm still too scared to try it 😂😂😂.
21points

#20

Hands placing eggs in a refrigerator filled with fruits, vegetables, and other common cooking ingredients.
My eggs are never room temperature when I bake. I’ve done it. Don’t notice any difference.
20points
51
11