Your phone buzzes with a payment notification, and suddenly your account balance is $5,000 higher. You don’t recognize the sender, and you certainly weren’t expecting that kind of money. A few minutes later, a frantic message arrives from someone claiming they accidentally sent you their rent money, emergency savings, or down payment. They apologize repeatedly and beg you to return it before something terrible happens. Sending the money back might seem like the decent thing to do, but that simple act could leave you thousands of dollars poorer.