
There are, it seems, three big questions still unanswered by science. One: why is there something rather than nothing (the case for God as creator); the second: how did life evolve from dead matter; and third, what is consciousness (and what is it for). It’s the third that Michael Pollan explores in A World Appears — to say he’s cracked it would be wrong. He has, however, got his readers thinking about it, possibly for the first time. Trouble is, as he observes, we have to use our consciousness to explore consciousness… this isn’t a subject we can investigate from outside.
The format could make for a dull book, except that Pollan is so honest, so interested and so clever that he turns the exercise into a journey through his own head — and other things besides. The structure does entail competing definitions of consciousness (“experience” is one plausible candidate) followed by our author interviewing one boffin after another, almost all men, about their particular theory.