James Gray may be one of our greatest contemporary novelistic directors. The director of films like The Immigrant, The Lost City of Z, and Ad Astra has always had a talent for crafting sprawling, yet intimate, epics, and his latest film, the languid crime thriller Paper Tiger, is no different. His second semi-autobiographical film after Armageddon Time, and initially envisioned as a sequel to his 2022 film, Paper Tiger is a mob movie that dances around mob violence; instead, unfolding mostly as a family drama in which the most terrifying bursts of violence are emotional ones. It can be a frustrating experience for those going in expecting some old-fashioned shoot-outs and mob intrigue, but Paper Tiger is a vastly more stirring and interesting film for it.