Finding new reasons for scepticism about BRICS has become a cottage industry. Around its New Delhi summit in September, commentators lined up to ask existential questions about the club, with some urging India to abandon it altogether. Much of the disappointment stems from BRICS' supposed failure to remake the global political order. India, in particular, is no closer to a permanent UNSC seat than it was two decades ago.
But such grand ambitions were always chimerical. India's BRICS presidency, which runs to the end of this year, won't rearrange great power relations. And it shouldn't try. The aim should be incremental progress in navigating a world that's fragmenting geopolitically, with an increasingly unreliable hegemon at centre stage.