In a Falcon breeding nuisance and negligence ruling, the Court of Appeal has upheld £258,500 in damages for a Cornwall falcon-breeding business, even though a majority of judges held the nuisance claim should have failed. Three falcons died after noise and visual disturbance from neighbouring scaffolding work, barn building and a broken-down digger during the 2022 breeding season. The award survived because two of the three judges found the neighbours also owed a duty of care in negligence. A sensitive business can therefore lose in nuisance yet still recover damages, where the neighbour knew the risk and could reasonably have avoided it. The decision highlights how negligence can provide a separate route to compensation when a neighbouring property's activities cause foreseeable harm to a specialist breeding operation.
Get breaking news anytime, anywhere. Download the TOI app now!