Yesterday's decision by Judge Indira Talwani (D. Mass.) in Planned Parenthood Fed. of Am., Inc. v. Kennedy (appeal pending) considered Section 71113(a) of the Reconciliation Act, which bars federal funding to any "entity, including its affiliates, subsidiaries, successors, and clinics," that provides abortions and satisfies certain other criteria (to oversimplify somewhat).
The court acknowledged that "Congress has long prohibited the use of any federal funds to reimburse the cost of abortions under the Medicaid program except in limited circumstances," and that "The Government can, without violating the Constitution, selectively fund a program to encourage certain activities it believes to be in the public interest, without at the same time funding an alternative program which seeks to deal with the problem in another way." But it concluded that the restriction on funding groups because of the actions of their affiliates violated the freedom of expressive association protected by the First Amendment. Here's a short excerpt from the long opinion:
Section 71113 does not merely "withhold[ ] funding based on whether entities provide abortion services," but also based on whether "an entity, including its affiliates," provides abortion services. And Defendants assert that "two entities' existence under common control" would satisfy the dictionary definition of an "affiliate," and that, in Defendants' view, Planned Parenthood Federations' "membership standards," "accreditation standards," and "shared medical standards and guidelines," would be sufficient to show common control such that Planned Parenthood Members who do not provide abortion could be "affiliates" of the Planned Parenthood Members who do.
To the extent that Section 71113 may be applied to Planned Parenthood Members who do not provide abortion, Plaintiffs are likely to succeed in establishing that the law impermissibly conditions the receipt of Medicaid funding on these Members foregoing their right to associate with Planned Parenthood Federation and other Members. Members who do not provide abortions cannot escape the law's burden except by disassociating from Members that do. And because Section 71113 may be applied to Members who are affiliates of each other via the structure, governance, and membership requirements of Planned Parenthood Federation, disassociating with other Members requires disassociating from Planned Parenthood Federation itself.