More than 500 people posted negative reviews on the book recommendations website Goodreads, urging Elizabeth Gilbert not to publish The Snow Forest. Like them, I haven’t read her novel. But I do know why her many fans were so distressed. The novel takes place in Siberia during the middle of the last century, and the objections to it have centered around the fact that its Russian setting would cause further pain to Ukrainians caught up in a defensive war against Vladimir Putin’s merciless aggression.
I met Elizabeth Gilbert once, at a dinner. The impression I got, and one that is sustained by her books – most notably, the immensely popular Eat, Pray, Love – is that of a kindly, thoughtful person who would never want to hurt those who have already suffered so much. According to an explanatory statement she issued, “I do not want to add any harm to a group of people who are continuing to experience grievous and extreme harm.” But while her choice to indefinitely postpone the book’s publication (formerly scheduled for February 2024) may have been made out of empathy, her decision, as well as the public outcry against the novel, was so ill-advised and unwise – for so many reasons – that it’s hard to know quite where to begin.
