While we’re still firmly in the feeling things out phase of the season, the 2026 campaign has already given us a few surprising developments (both of the positive and negative variety). Just take a look at the standings: the Twins have the best record in the American League, while the Red Sox, Mets and Cubs are in last place. Things are likely to even out, but that doesn’t mean what’s transpired so far is not worth further examination.
Starting with the American League, here’s a look at the most surprising player for each team. For better or worse, each name has had an unexpected start to the season, and we’ll examine whether these beginnings are just a blip on the radar or the start of a new trend.
