NEW YORK — With the game on the line, as he always does, Yankees pitching coach Matt Blake scrutinized his ace. Gerrit Cole had left a four-seamer over the plate to the Guardians’ Steven Kwan and watched it land in the right field stands. He had hit the next batter, and the one after that had doubled. Blake had trudged to the mound to remind Cole to keep the moment small, to focus pitch by pitch, to miss in the right places.
Now, perched in the dugout during the third inning of the first game of the American League Division Series, Blake watched Cole’s face. Blake saw intention. He watched the way Cole took his time climbing the rubber. Blake saw control. He watched Cole face the next batter. Blake saw potential for catastrophe.
Cole induced a ground ball; first baseman Anthony Rizzo fielded it and threw to catcher José Trevino, who threw to third baseman Josh Donaldson. They failed to record the out. With one out and the bases loaded, the next batter grounded to Donaldson; he went home for the out instead of trying for the double play. Bases loaded, two out. With a 1–2 count to Andres Giménez, Cole’s slider clipped the bottom of the zone but was called ball 2.