Ananya
Hi Team, I just saw the discussion on Satluj with Hartosh. I can understand the issue of inflated numbers and how that dilutes the battle for truth and reconciliation in Punjab. However, I was very disappointed with how the entire panel framed the issue as ‘propaganda’ and the kind of embarrassing parallels drawn to The Kashmir Files (which Hartosh admitted he had not watched!). I’d urge you to read Anurag Minus Verma's essay on The Kashmir Files in The Print and read more in detail about the politics of truth, realism, and propaganda in cinema to at least define these terms with an adequate sense of media literacy. Bad and good films can be propaganda! Propaganda is not bad in itself! Please read more about film history or at least include a film/cultural studies scholar (not a reviewer) on your panel if discussing a complex film like Satluj. PS: The Hathras docuseries is also on Zee5, and the UP elections are around the corner! Conspiracy anyone?