In the history of the Heisman Trophy, which dates back to 1935, just five wide receivers have won the award—and they’ve often had to play other roles to get over the hump. The first, Nebraska’s Johnny Rodgers (1972), also played running back and returned punts. Notre Dame’s Tim Brown (1987) did the same, scoring as many touchdowns as a punt returner (three) as a wide receiver. Ditto Desmond Howard (1991), who scored rushing, kick and punt return touchdowns for Michigan along with his 19 receiving touchdowns. Colorado’s Travis Hunter (2024) may be the most famous example, serving as arguably college football’s best cornerback and wide receiver during his Heisman campaign.
That leaves Alabama’s DeVonta Smith, the 2020 winner, as the only player to win almost entirely on the strength of his wide receiver numbers (although he did score a rushing touchdown and returned a punt for a score that year). But Smith, like the other four wide receiver Heisman winners, was the only player at his position to receive any first-place votes in the year in which he won. Historically, it has been very difficult for any receivers to make the requisite noise to box out the legions of quarterbacks who’ve dominated the voting, especially since the turn of the millennium.