Heisman Trophies aren’t won in September … well, usually. There are some examples—Tim Brown’s two punt return touchdowns in Notre Dame’s second game of the 1987 season against Michigan State were enough to overcome the Fighting Irish’s 8–3 finish—but for the most part the wheat takes a few weeks to separate from the chaff. Few of the famous “Heisman moments” take place in Week 1.
That is especially informative this season because of a dearth of great Week 1 matchups on paper. If anything, we’re in a holding pattern because so many of the top names entering the season lived up to the billing in their season debuts.