Back in 2019 it already seemed urgent to write something about human relationships with machines: robots, neural networks, and artificial intelligence. To me the extraordinary and undertapped creative potential of flesh-and-blood people was one of the reasons why we matter. Creativity defines humanity. One of us is unique and distinctive no matter how many extraterrestrial life-forms may exist. The idea that machines could or should take over making art or writing diminishes the work of teachers, of human-authored books about how to make art and to write, and the fact that people can learn stuff. Yet even a scholar of literature (my Providence colleague) could envision a life of idleness consuming algorithm-generated content as progress. What did that say about the value people placed on appreciating things made by humans rather than by machines? Were human experience and creativity going to become redundant, and, if so, who would we even be? By deciding what robots are for, we are defining what humans are.
Fast-forward to 2024. Stories about generative AI are everywhere. Human labor is increasingly framed as an obstacle to corporate profits. Authors, artists, and their guilds are suing companies like OpenAI that are using the “fair use” clause in copyright law—a law devised to enable human beings to quote one another briefly, giving due credit to the author they’re quoting, without the trouble and expense of paying for permission to reproduce other people’s work—to feed copyrighted works into their LLMs (large language models).