
It’s officially been eight and a half years since the release of Persona 5 — that’s nearly a year longer than the time that passed between when we got Persona 4 and Persona 5. But there’s been a Persona game nearly every year in that time, with a whopping eight games released in the interim. But while playing the latest spinoff, Persona 5: The Phantom X, I had a thought that only kept resurfacing more and more — the series is starting to feel worryingly stagnant. Persona 5 was the series watershed moment, when it finally hit the mainstream, but everything else since has been following in its footsteps. What happens when one of the most innovative RPG franchises of all time, can no longer figure out how to innovate itself?
It’s not a stretch to say Persona 5, especially the updated Royal version, is one of the best RPGs ever made. In 2016 it turned the franchise into a phenomenon, and eclipsed the sales of pretty much everything else Atlus has ever made. Just for perspective, we recently learned that Persona 5 Royal sold 7.25 million units. Compare that to Shin Megami Tensei V at 2.1 million, or Person 4 Golden’s 1 million sales. With the difference between those numbers, it’s easy to see why Persona 5 has gotten so many spinoffs, but that’s also my biggest worry with the franchise right now — nothing has been able to escape the shadow of Persona 5, and I mean that in multiple layers.