Anthony Volpe has had about every opportunity imaginable to succeed with the Yankees. The franchise’s first-round pick in 2019, and a New York native, there was some hope that Volpe could develop into a franchise cornerstone and the team’s long-term solution at shortstop.
Since Derek Jeter retired, the Yankees have deployed 15 different players at shortstop, ranging from Didi Gregorius to this year’s tandem of Volpe and José Caballero. None have lasted more than four years, and it really felt as if the team wanted Volpe to be the next organizational success story and Jeter’s heir apparent. The team even gave Volpe the No. 11 jersey, which, considering the amount of low jersey numbers retired by the franchise, was seen as a sign of their belief in him.