From Justice Sotomayor's statement respecting the denial of review today in Gonzalez v. U.S., joined by Justice Gorsuch:
Founding-era common law gave officers no authority to make an "arrest without a warrant, for a mere misdemeanor not committed in [their] presence." Bad Elk v. United States (1900) (collecting sources). This petition asks the Court to decide whether the Fourth Amendment incorporates that "in-the-presence" limitation on warrantless misdemeanor arrests. There is reason to think it might. After all, the in-the-presence requirement existed in some form at the founding. This Court has often held, moreover, that the Fourth Amendment "'must provide at a minimum the degree of protection'" the common law afforded at the time of its adoption. Lange v. California, (2021)…
On an early July morning, around 5 o'clock, two Miami Dade police officers encountered petitioner Victor Gonzalez "'walking in the middle of the street'" in a residential neighborhood. The officers, who had received a 911 call reporting a "'white male casing the area,'" engaged Gonzalez in brief conversation and arrested him for the Florida misdemeanor of "loitering and prowling." They performed a search incident to the arrest, which revealed several pieces of mail addressed to neighborhood residents. A grand jury thereafter charged Gonzalez with possessing stolen mail, a federal felony….
.png?w=600)
