While I await an assessment of Nicola Sturgeon’s career from a non-unionist perspective from the fair-minded Guardian, I’ll take issue with Martin Kettle on just one of his criticisms (Nicola Sturgeon’s immense political talent is undeniable, 14 August).
He states that Sturgeon’s “gender recognition reforms were dogmatic and divisive”. After lengthy consultation, the gender recognition reform (Scotland) bill was passed by the Scottish parliament with a significant majority, the Conservatives being the only party voting against. If it had been enacted, Scotland would have aligned with the majority of European countries on this issue. However, the UK government used section 35 of the Scotland Act to stop it. So the dogma and divisiveness came from the UK, not Sturgeon or the Scottish government, and Scotland and the UK remain conservative outliers in Europe with regard to trans rights.
John Warburton
Edinburgh
