I like the trend of re-grading grades. While you could argue it’s a natural evolution of the content cycle—creating content from content—I think it’s an important way to stop, raise our hands and say “my bad.” We don’t do enough of that in sports analysis, and we certainly don’t do enough of it in life. Not revisiting a grade, like we’re about to do on this season’s 10 first-year head coaches at the midway point, suggests infallibility. Far more interesting is digging back into what we thought at the time and why we think differently now.
The relevance of the head coaching position is making a roaring comeback this season. John Harbaugh has the Giants in first place. Mike McCarthy has the Steelers in first place. Joe Brady has the Bills in first place. Todd Monken had the Browns in first place. Klint Kubiak won his first three games as head coach and has one of the NFL passing leaders in … Kirk Cousins. Most teams that changed head coaches this offseason have seen an immediate return on investment (quick, someone tell Jerry Jones).