Georgetown professor William English conducted a "2021 National Firearms Survey," which is available on SSRN.com. The latest version, the "expanded report," was published in 2022. In 2024, five professors, led by Harvard's Deborah Azrael authored a critique of the survey, forthcoming in the SMU Law Review. Her coauthors are Joseph Blocher (Duke, law), Philip J. Cook (Duke, public policy), David Hemenway (Harvard, public health), and Matthew Miller (Northeastern & Harvard, public health). In November 2024, English published a detailed response to the critique, as a working paper for the University of Wyoming's Firearms Research Center, where I am a senior fellow. Then in December 2024, Azrael et al. revised their article to include an addendum (pages 24-26) responding English's November paper. In this Post, I will evaluate the pro/con arguments presented by the various authors. [Bracketed inserts] in summaries of what the authors said are by me.
In short:
- English's estimate of a 32% individual adult gun ownership rates is consistent with other surveys.
- His estimates of defensive gun uses (DGUs) — 1.67 million times a year, with a shot fired in about 300,000 — is credible, if one believes that DGUs can be measured at all.
- His age distribution of DGUs seems counterintuitive, and might be contradicted by further studies.
- His estimates of a total national stock of about 44 million rifles that are inaccurately called "assault weapons" could be too high or too low, because of the phrasing of his question. However, other research, when combined with known data other firearms in this category, leads to a minimum national supply easily over 30 million.
- English's estimate that 48% of gun owners own a magazine with 10 round capacity is undisputed.