When Russia designated the Human Rights Foundation as "undesirable" earlier this year, the New York City–based nonprofit knew what was coming next. In September, the HRF received a notice demanding it block Russians from accessing its signature Tyranny Tracker. But the notice did not come from Russia; it came from WP Engine, a web hosting company headquartered in Austin, Texas.
"What troubled us was that an American company passed that demand on to us nonchalantly as if it created a legal obligation," says Javier El-Hage, chief legal and policy officer at HRF. The Kremlin's censorship agency, Roskomnadzor, contacted WP Engine with a demand to block Tyranny Tracker from Russia. WP Engine complied, telling the HRF that if it did not geo-block Tyranny Tracker, the web hosting company would "geo-block the site on [the HRF's] behalf." An American company censoring an American nonprofit at the behest of a foreign government—dutifully passing the order along as if it were an overdue library book notice.