MLB’s original Shohei Ohtani sweepstakes found itself consumed by questions of fit.
In the winter of 2017, as Ohtani embarked on the process that ultimately led him to join the Angels, these questions kept popping up alongside the ordinary queries about what a player wants and where he might go. These felt more existential. How will video games handle a two-way player? Will statisticians do anything different to calculate his WAR? Is it fair to call him a “utility player”—does baseball need a new vocabulary to describe him? How will his team balance his workload? What should be the benchmark for greatness here? Not all of these questions hoped to find answers, exactly. They functioned more as simple reminders: The modern game was not built for a player like Ohtani. To fit, baseball would need to break some of its structures and, in turn, expand its imagination.
Now, these questions seem almost quaint. All of those systems proved accommodating (or accommodating enough). The game figured it out, and the conversation moved on. There isn’t much of a point in marveling at simple novelty here anymore. Ohtani’s talent is a novelty unto itself: Why ponder where he fits in various game structures when you can just watch him? Any individual game might offer a stat line never seen in a box score before. All the questions about how this greatness works have fallen behind those about what it means, where it might find its limits and how lucky we are to watch it at all.