
The shock announcement of Chipotle CEO Brian Niccol taking the helm of Starbucks following former boss Laxman Narasimhan’s departure was a much-needed jolt to the coffee giant’s stock: Company shares were up 22% the day after the news, with investors rallying around the potential for a turnaround in Starbucks’ slump.
The cause for celebration may be a little premature, Jefferies analysts believe. In a Monday note, Jefferies managing director Andy Barish downgraded Starbucks’ stock to a rare hold and cut the company to underperform, the equivalent of a sell rating. It’s the first time the analyst has given a sell-equivalent rating since beginning to cover the company in 2011, according to Bloomberg data.