
When Doctor Who aired its first Christmas special in 2005, it was almost shocking that the beloved BBC sci-fi series hadn’t been making them all this time. Doctor Who and Christmas seem like a match made in TV heaven: the sweet, corny whimsy of Doctor Who goes perfectly with the cozy decadence of the Christmas holidays. And after you’ve stuffed yourself full of yams and roast beast, there’s no better dessert than watching the Doctor save the day from a holiday-themed sci-fi baddie.
Inverse’s Doctor Who fans put their heads together to rank all the Christmas specials. Excluded from this ranking are the “End of Time” episodes (since the two-parter is more 10th Doctor send-off than Christmas special) and the off-holiday specials like Jodie Whittaker’s New Year’s specials. Here are all the Doctor Who Christmas specials so far, ranked.