On Tuesday, Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson self-reported emerging concussion symptoms that he was initially checked for in the first quarter of Sunday’s blowout loss to the Steelers. This means that on Sunday against the Saints, Cleveland needs to draw from its reserves and turn to a quarterback—possibly Shedeur Sanders—that the team avoided turning to after a summer-long competition.
Outside of Cleveland’s first-year head coach, Todd Monken, clearly seeing Watson as the better player out of camp (even though Watson has had some encouraging big-game moments this season, he is 28th in ESPN’s all-encompassing total QBR quarterback rating, 20th in EPA per play, 17th in success rate per down, 17th in completion percentage over expectation and 27th in air yards per pass), turning to Sanders risks the chance of activating the Sanders hive, which is a curious group of delusion-seekers adamantly tied to the idea that Sanders is the Browns’ answer at quarterback. This despite a small but alarming sample size in which Sanders was one of the NFL’s worst quarterbacks and a major negative outlier in both interception-worthy and uncatchable throws last year. While I’m not saying the Browns have much of a choice this weekend, as Sanders has been operating as the No. 2 quarterback on the depth chart, and I’m not ruling out the idea that Sanders, like many players, got better, I am saying that Cleveland has a more consequential choice it needs to make as we approach next week’s trade deadline.