Large, established journalistic publications, amorphously clubbed together as “mainstream media”, are often portrayed as villains online. Politically convenient ideas and blatant misinformation are shared as “things that the mainstream media will never tell you”; and the belief that “mainstream media” has certain “agendas” is a driving force of the online misinformation mills. This repeated messaging across social media is reflected in studies that show a declining trust in established news outlets.
The distrust is more evident now as the fault lines in West Asia have opened up once again. To cite an example, a headline from The New York Times had initially stated that an Israeli strike had caused the explosion and fire at the Al-Ahli Arab Hospital in Gaza on Tuesday. The headline was later revised to avoid Israeli involvement, drawing intense scrutiny online. The original headline was seen as evidence of the publication being biased towards information emerging from the Palestinian side. Incidentally, in the pro-Palestine sections of social media, The New York Times is seen to support Israel and its policies.
The BBC in the U.K., too, faced such a predicament when one of its initial social media posts on the current violence spoke of many Israelis having been “killed” while many Palestinians had “died”. The choice of words was the subject of a viral video from a Palestine supporter, who claimed it was evidence of Western media’s pro-Israel bias. Meanwhile, in pro-Israel circles, the BBC is seen as being biased towards the Palestinian cause. In fact, the BBC has so far received about 1,500 complaints regarding its coverage of the current conflict, and as per a report in The Guardian, the complaints are evenly split between those alleging a pro-Palestine bias and those alleging a pro-Israel bias. This reminds one of many a veteran journalist’s adage that “if both sides are not happy, we are doing something right.”