As is often true of criminal defendants who ask the Supreme Court to review their cases, Derick Irisha Brown is, to put it mildly, not a sympathetic petitioner. But notwithstanding the horrifying details of her crimes, which involved the kidnapping of a 3-year-old girl who reportedly was sexually abused and "accidentally killed" by her boyfriend, her petition raises an issue that goes to the heart of the constitutional distinction between state and federal powers.
In a case that has not yet gone to trial, Brown is charged with capital murder under Alabama law, which means she would face the death penalty or a life sentence without the possibility of parole if convicted. But in September 2024, a jury convicted her of federal kidnapping charges, which resulted in two concurrent life sentences. The justification for that prosecution was that Brown used a car to kidnap the victim, which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit said was enough, by itself, to establish federal jurisdiction under the Commerce Clause.