
The Watcher (Jeffrey Wright) is the one thing that keeps What If...? from being a straightforward anthology. The all-knowing, all-seeing being serves as the show’s dutiful narrator, who observes alternate timelines from a distance. It’s his task to watch over Marvel’s multiverse without tampering with its events, but it wasn’t until What If’s third season that casual Marvel fans really understood why.
What If Season 3 indulges in a bit of backstory, introducing the Watcher on his first day on the job. Having been mentored by the Eminence (Jason Isaacs), our Watcher has learned to observe impartially, forgoing any bias and any semblance of his identity to protect the multiverse. The Watcher even gives up his own name to serve, and he knows that going back on his oath will compromise the integrity of the Order of the Watchers. But as we’ve seen across three seasons of What If, the Watcher’s aloofness doesn’t last. He first breaks his oath in Season 1, forging the Guardians of the Multiverse to preserve humanity. And he’s meddled plenty since, saving entire timelines from what he’s deemed unnecessary destruction.