During the 2026 session, Utah's legislature amended Utah's rules of evidence, adding a new provision (subsection 404(d)). The new provision allows prosecutors to present to juries sexual assault propensity evidence in sexual assault cases. The Federal Rules of Evidence have contained a similar rule (Rule 413) for more than two decades. Numerous states follow comparable approaches—either through rule or caselaw—tracking the common law approach of admitting evidence to prove a "lustful disposition." Utah's rules will now benefit from a provision codifying this approach in Rule 404(d).
Because of the significance of this new rule change, I've written an article with Utah County prosecutor Ryan McBride explaining the rationale behind it and how it will operate in practice. The article makes four arguments in favor of the new rule.
First, because most sex crimes are committed by perpetrators against victims in private places, admitting evidence of similar crimes is often critical to a successful prosecution of those perpetrators. In light of frequently conflicting testimony from victims and defendants in sexual assault cases, admitting similar crimes evidence serves to arm the jury with more information from which to determine the truth and reach an accurate verdict. When the defendant claims to have been unjustly accused, allowing evidence of other acts of misconduct often puts an entirely different light on the matter. Combining direct evidence of guilt with evidence of the defendant's past crimes may thus eliminate reasonable doubt in a case that would otherwise be inconclusive. As Utah Senator Orrin Hatch concluded in co-sponsoring legislation adding Rule 413 to the Federal Rules of Evidence, the public interest in admitting evidence "that will illuminate the credibility of the charge and any denial by the defense is truly compelling." Letter from Sen. Orrin G. Hatch, Rep. Susan Molinari, and Rep. John Kyl to Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist 2 (Oct. 11, 1994).