The College Football Playoff committee can deny it, but they’re just not that into backup quarterbacks. Second-string signal-callers haven’t been the committee’s type since 2023, when an undefeated Florida State team sans Jordan Travis was famously snubbed from the playoff because the committee feared what might happen to a Seminoles team led by a backup QB while conveniently ignoring what had actually happened on the field.
The Travis rule was born that day, and, despite just one member of the 2023–24 committee holding over to ’26–27, the principle has lingered. The logic was applied last week in the committee’s initial rankings to the Ohio State Buckeyes, who toiled through a loss to USC in freshman signal-caller Luke Fahey’s first start with Julian Sayin sidelined.