At first glance, the White Sox sending starting pitchers Davis Martin and Luis Castillo to the Rockies on Thursday for a pair of unheralded prospects may appear bizarre and even scornworthy. Why would a team that’s already hurting for starters trade away a pitcher who recorded a 3.95 ERA in 146 innings last season just to dump Castillo’s one-year contract?
It’s not as if Chicago and its bottom-10 projected 2027 payroll necessarily needed to rid itself of Castillo, who carries an onerous $24 million salary yet doesn’t represent a long-term cost. Chicago’s sudden transformation into a playoff team is the sort of metamorphosis that usually portends the addition of arms rather than subtraction. Signing Dustin May this week only to sever ties with Castillo and Martin could be seen as taking one step forward and two steps back.