Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Reason
Reason
Eugene Volokh

RARE PHOTOS: Would muslim prayer room at public high school violate establishment clause | Rare Historical Photos

Yes, Judge John Milton Younge (E.D. Pa.) suggested Friday in Hiester v. School District of Philadelphia:

The crux of Plaintiffs' allegations is that the School District and its officials established a Muslim Prayer Room at one of its high schools, the Academy at Palumbo …. Plaintiffs claim that the room was restricted to Muslim students, and that they were unfairly disciplined by the Defendants for entering the Prayer Room because they are not Muslim….

The Supreme Court requires that the Establishment Clause be interpreted by "reference to historical practices and understandings." To prevail on an Establishment Clause claim, a plaintiff must show that the challenged government action "resemble[s] a traditional hallmark of religious establishment." The Third Circuit has identified six of these hallmarks:

"First, the government exerted control over the doctrine and personnel of the established church. Second, the government mandated attendance in the established church and punished people for failing to participate. Third, the government punished dissenting churches and individuals for their religious exercise. Fourth, the government restricted political participation by dissenters. Fifth, the government provided financial support for the established church, often in a way that preferred the established denomination over other churches. And sixth, the government used the established church to carry out certain civil functions, often by giving the established church a monopoly over a specific function."

To prevail on their Establishment Clause claim, Plaintiffs only need to show that SDP's Prayer/Quiet Room policy "resembles one" of these hallmarks.

Student Plaintiffs plausibly allege that Defendants … suspended them for entering the Muslim Prayer Room as non-Muslims. They also plausibly allege that they were suspended to pacify Palumbo students' outrage, thereby reinforcing the student body's perception that the Prayer Room was available to Muslim students only. In this respect, the defendants' actions resemble the fourth hallmark of religious establishment: "the government restrict[ing] political participation by dissenters."

The Plaintiffs also plausibly allege that Defendants … used public resources to create the Prayer Room and prevent non-Muslim students from accessing it. The room was on the grounds of a publicly funded school and was used during school hours. In this respect, Defendants' actions resemble the fifth hallmark of religious establishment: "the government provid[ing] financial support for the established church, often in a way that prefer[s] the established denomination over other churches."

The school defendants argued that the room was actually open "to all students who wished to pray, meditate, or reflect privately," and Muslim students just happened to use the room more often than other students. But plaintiffs had alleged—plausibly, the court concluded—that they were indeed disciplined for entering the room as non-Muslims, citing "The Police Report filed in response to Defendant Thompson's complaint wherein she stated that the room is 'designated for a particular religion and having a certain flag [Palestinian] outside the room'":

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.