Supreme Court's Oct 15 judgment in the Yes Bank AT-1 bond case raises a question beyond the fate of Rs 8,415 cr of investors' money: when an administrator's decision is held unlawful, who examines the decision-maker's conduct, and under what legal framework? The court upheld Bombay High Court's decision setting aside the permanent write-down of the bonds. Appeals by Yes Bank, RBI and Union of India were dismissed.
The judgment settles the legality of the write-down. But institutional accountability requires examining not only the decision but also the circumstances in which it was made.