Bored Panda
40 Times Goodwill Surprised People With Their Hidden Gems Or Bizarre Items
CuriositiesAPR 26, 2025

FORGOTTEN HISTORY: Funny interesting goodwill finds - Caught on Camera

75
6
Thrifting is easy, you just walk in for a t-shirt and leave with a traffic light, grass slippers, and a newly found personality trait. To show everyone how it's done, some people even form online communities where they post pictures of their proudest scores.
r/Goodwill_Finds is basically a digital museum of chaos and treasure — part fashion show, part fever dream, and 100% proof that someone's trash really can be your new favorite thing. If you're brave enough to take it home and explain yourself to your partner, that is.

#1 Best Find Lmao

Framed bizarre artwork from Goodwill featuring surprised figures and a cat at a dinner table on a grid wall.
Report
133points

#2 Scored This Full Set For $60

Retro Coca-Cola table and red chairs in a sunlit patio, a hidden gem find at Goodwill.
117points

Some people have noticed a change in recent years in Goodwill prices. Instead of finding incredible bargains like $2 tops and $0.50 books, they are encountering higher prices, sometimes even surpassing those of new items at Walmart or Target.

"Goodwill's rising prices can be attributed to several factors," said Casey Jones, founder and head of marketing and finance at CJ&CO. "Firstly, the cost of operations — including rent, utilities, and wages — has increased over time. Secondly, the quality and brand of donated items can also influence pricing. High-end brands or items in excellent condition may be priced higher."

"Lastly, the demand for thrifted items has grown, especially among environmentally conscious consumers, which can drive up prices."

#3 Almost $400 Wagon I Got For $30. My Dog Has No Idea The Adventures She’s In For

Blue and gray bike trailer at Goodwill, a hidden gem find.
Report
101points

#4 Thankful For The Goodwill Employee Who Priced This At $4

Ornate, iridescent lantern found at Goodwill, showcasing unique design and colorful reflections in a living room.
93points

#5 Pigeon Painting

Pigeon reading a book titled "Pooping on People" in a collection of thrift store hidden gems.
92points

However, despite the increasing popularity and prices of secondhand shops, these pictures are proof that amazing deals can still be found.

"Most people go to Goodwill one singular time within a span of four months and don't find anything that day and then assume they can't find anything at Goodwill and don't go back," said photographer Brooke Fitzwater, who loves to browse secondhand aisles.

"Stock at Goodwill is constantly in flux, so sometimes you might go and find a ton of stuff and sometimes you might go and find absolutely nothing. The only way to increase your chances of finding good stuff is to go frequently."

#6 Found At Baton Rouge Goodwill-I Think It’s Handmade

Patchwork quilt on a patio, an unexpected Goodwill gem with colorful rectangular patches and orange trim.
90points

#7 I Found A US Made, 100% Camel Hair Coat Today For $6.99

Person wearing a tan blazer and a graphic t-shirt with "Haiti" text, showcasing a hidden gem found at Goodwill.
88points

#8 Roommate Found A Vintage Wedding Dress For $40, The Kicker Is That It Fits Her Perfectly!

Person in an elaborate vintage white wedding dress found at Goodwill.
82points

Brooke said, "You can go once a month, once a week, or even once a day (that's dedication!), and you will be much more likely to find something incredible than if you just go every once in a blue moon."

"During the past semester, I would go either once every three weeks or once every two weeks, depending upon my schedule, and occasionally I would go once a week if I was really looking for something. I found so much more than I did when I just went every once in a while."

#9 I Had Been Eyeing This Exact Pair On Ebay For Over A Year And I Found Them At Goodwill For 9 Dollars In My Size! They Were 100 On Ebay

Vintage Nike high tops discovered at Goodwill, showcasing unique style and hidden gems appeal.
80points

#10 I Used To Work At Goodwill And Someone Once Donated A Traffic Light

Traffic light display at Goodwill featuring colorful lights in an unexpected setting, showcasing a unique hidden gem.
76points

#11 Ohh Yeah!

Smiling face jug found as a hidden gem at Goodwill, placed on a wooden table.
75points

#12 Genuine Leather Harley Davidson Jacket For 10 Dollars

Black leather jacket with silver zippers found as a hidden gem at Goodwill, placed on a beige chair.
75points

Another way you get the most out of Goodwill, the seasoned thrifter said, is by making use of their special promos.

"If your Goodwill has sales (Goodwill of Middle Tennessee has lots of awesome sales), utilize them! My personal favorite is the color tag sales. Each Goodwill item has a tag that has a specific color (like orange or blue), and some Goodwill stores like the ones in my area will have weekly sales where all items with one color tag will be 50% off for that week, and items with a different tag color will be 0.99 cents!" Fitzwater explained.

"I cannot tell you how many things I have been able to find for 0.99 cents. I once found a Madewell cardigan that was originally $75 for 0.99 cents at Goodwill, as well as several lovely sweaters and a few other great items. This is your best deal. If you're lucky, you can find some really great brands for really low prices."

#13 Left This Lil Cutie Behind

Framed artwork of a rabbit in a mask pushing a shopping cart, found at Goodwill.
68points

#14 Scored Brain Anatomy Glass Coasters For 7$

Stacked brain model on display, a hidden gems item found at Goodwill, sparking curiosity and surprise.
68points

#15 Walnut Bowl. Literally Made Of Walnuts

A decorative bowl made from metal chains, a hidden gem found at Goodwill, placed on a wooden table.
Report
66points

#16 Found At A Goodwill In Dallas

Person in a mirror selfie wearing a fitted red dress and metallic heels, showcasing a Goodwill hidden gem find.
66points

Whatever happens, if you have a mission, stick to it. Fitzwater said, "You might go two or three times and find nothing. At that point, it might feel like it's hopeless, but don't give up hope!"

"I like to think of Goodwill as a treasure hunt. Eventually, I'm going to find that piece that I've been wanting, and it will have been worth the wait. Just keep trying! You can also try other Goodwill stores near you, or maybe you can try going with a Goodwill-savvy friend. Try things that you wouldn't normally choose, or try something on just for the fun of it. You never know what you might find!"

#17 Love At 1st Sight

Illuminated vintage globe on a wooden stand, a hidden gem found at Goodwill.
65points

#18 Goodwill Came Thru Today. $19.99

Breville espresso machine found at Goodwill, a hidden gem on display with controls and steam wand visible.
Report
64points

#19 Found This Gem!

Stanley vacuum bottle in box, a thrift store gem found at Goodwill, resting on a brown sofa.
Report
64points

#20 Pressed Flowers Framed Found At My Local Goodwill

Ornate gold-framed floral artwork, a hidden gem discovered at Goodwill.
62points
75
6