Bored Panda
“I've Seen Both”: 58 People Share The Folklore That Made Them Believe There Might Be Something Out There

UNBELIEVABLE: North america folklore stories | History Defined

37
11
We’ve all heard plenty about North America, from famously large portion sizes and busy cities to Hollywood, road trips, and some of the world's most recognizable pop culture. But there's another side to the continent that's far older, stranger, and a little more unsettling. North America is home to countless legends, ghost stories, and mysterious creatures passed down through generations, many rooted in local history, cultural traditions, and the landscapes where these stories began.
And that's exactly what we went looking for today. We dove into a thread where people answered the question, “What’s the most haunting folklore of North America?” From chilling local legends to strange beings said to lurk in forests, lakes, and along lonely roads, the answers reveal a mysterious side of the continent that doesn't always make it into travel brochures. Some of these tales are frightening, others fascinating, and a few might make you think twice the next time you're alone in the woods. Keep scrolling, Pandas, to discover the haunting stories that have captured people's imaginations for generations.

This post may include affiliate links.

#1

Dark, misty forest evokes chilling North American folklore.
The Wendigos stories are probably the creepiest to me. The idea of a person becoming a monster because of greed and starvation is already disturbing, but the stories about hearing something in the woods make it even worse.

WonderClean6418:

Wendigo: It gets taller and hungrier with every person it eats. And winter makes it worse.
26points

#2

A carved stone marker stands in a dimly lit forest, evoking North American folklore and chills.
Everybody's got the usuals covered. One of the more minor haunt characters is a little ghost girl called blue eyes, that resides on a military base in Ontario. Every part of the story can be explained logically, except for the GPS navigation. No matter where you start, or where you punch in your destination, it'll take you to her grave.
24points

#3

Intricately carved totem pole representing the diverse North American folklore and its chills.
Moon eyed people. Native Americans knew of a group of small pale folk with large round eyes that were mostly nocturnal. They had peaceful relationships with them for many generations. Eventually there was war that wiped the Moon eyes out. The native stories treat this as history instead of myth. No one really knows wtah this beings were.
23points

Many of us probably grew up hearing stories from our grandparents, parents, or other family members—perhaps tales about ancient heroes, mysterious creatures, gods, witches, or strange things that supposedly happened long ago. These stories are often part of folklore, a broad collection of shared traditions, beliefs, customs, and tales passed down from one generation to the next, often through word of mouth and everyday practices. Some explain the world around us, while others entertain, teach lessons, preserve cultural memories, or simply give us a good reason to fear the woods after dark. And while today's post explores some of North America's most haunting folklore, let's also take a quick trip around the world and look at a few legendary figures and creatures that have captured people's imaginations for generations.

#4

A man's hand holding an axe in a field, symbolizing terrifying North American folklore.
Hatchet Woman.

dunno if there's a specific origin but I became aware of it in the Rockies. The timeline is ambiguous but may have originated some time in the early 1900s.

A homeless woman had her camp outside of town high up on the ridge. She had built herself a nest and would frequently be seen wandering the ridge with her hatchet, cutting down saplings to add to her nest.

Occasionally, youths from town would harass her, throwing rocks, shouting, enticing her to chase them, etc.

She was by all accounts a frail old woman so this seemed like a risk-free bullying for the children.

Until one day the kids didn't come back down the ridge after running off to bother Hatchet Woman. Eventually adults went up to look for them and found each and every one passed away from a hatchet blow to the head. The adults went immediately to Hatchet Woman's nest to confront her but she was gone.

They never found her, but for years after, anyone who dared venture up the ridge would be found later, hacked.

Even to this day, NO ONE goes up that ridge after dark and it's considered proper to leave an offering of a large stick "at least as tall as a man" on the trail as an offering to Hatchet Woman for safe passage. The trail is LINED with almost a wicker wall of large sticks, and to take one away is to invite violent demise.
23points

#5

A wicker basket rests on mossy forest ground, hinting at mysterious North American folklore.
My kids learn some coast Salish history and language as part of the school curriculum. The Basket Lady scared the heck out of them. She hangs around in the forest with a basket made of cedar, and steals children who stay out too late.
22points

#6

A wolf in a dark forest, representing North American folklore that still gives people chills.
There is the Dogman in Northern MI.

It's okay though he only shows up on the 7th year of the decade. Oh, that's next year.

Also Bigfoot and Wendigo.
18points

Let's start with two larger-than-life figures featured in B.A. Botkin's A Treasury of American Folklore. First published in 1944 and supported by the Federal Writers' Project, the collection brought together a remarkable range of oral traditions, tall tales, songs, jokes, and stories from diverse American communities. One of its most famous figures is Paul Bunyan, the mythical giant lumberjack whose adventures became a staple of American and Canadian folklore. Originally told as exaggerated campfire stories by loggers, Paul Bunyan's larger-than-life exploits often explained how landscapes and landmarks came to be. With his enormous strength and equally enormous companion, Babe the Blue Ox, Bunyan became a symbol of the rugged frontier spirit and proof that a good story only gets better when you make everything a little bigger.

#7

A snow-covered house at dusk with glowing windows, evoking North American folklore and chills.
The House of Blue Lights is a local Indianapolis legend and once rite of passage to sneak into. It was one I learned about from my dad. Legend said it was owned by a rich recluse who kept his late wife who passed away] in an accident in a glass coffin surrounded by these blue eerie Christmas lights. Didn’t help the house had gotten some bizarre add on construction through the years to sell the kooky rich old man energy. Plus The house had the blue Christmas lights on all year around hence its name.

Well turns out the man in question Skiles Edward Test was something of an eccentric. He was married three times and his wives all outlived him. The man loved blue and initially found the legends cropping up about his house to be funny until he had to put up with constant teenage vandalism and several house fires.

Skiles passed from stress and when he passed wanted his house to be turned into a nature preserve or a camping spot for the Boy Scouts.
17points

#8

Misty North American mountains under a cloudy sky evoke chills from folklore.
The Appalachian Mountains. There is a thread on here somewhere about the stuff that people see there. Missing kids etc. the staircases. Creeps me out.

susaneec:

I live in the southern Appalachians. It's beautiful here, truly. The mountains appear so gentle and green. But there are hollers that will swallow you. Between the caves and the bears and the people, you almost don't need anything else to make it dangerous for the unwary. But these mountains are older than bones. If there's a place in the world where the earth stores memories, for better or for worse, it's here.
15points

#9

A woman in a white dress standing in water, a common image in North American folklore tales.
Hancock Hannah!

Imagine the hillbilly version of La Llorona. Hancock Hannah spends the nights roaming the fresh water lake, Hancock Pond, weeping for her late children. The multitude of critters out at night, seemingly mimicking the cries, did not ease my six year old little heart after my grandpa told me the story lol.
15points

Then there's Davy Crockett, another famous figure whose story sits somewhere between history and legend. Unlike Paul Bunyan, Crockett was real: a frontiersman, soldier, politician, and folk hero who lived in the early 19th century. But as his story was retold through almanacs, books, stage productions, and later television, his real-life adventures gradually grew into the legend of the “King of the Wild Frontier.” The fictionalized version of Crockett became larger than life, complete with incredible survival skills and a famous coonskin cap. His story is a fascinating example of how a real historical figure can become part of folklore as generations add a little more adventure to the tale.

#10

A person with a flashlight in a dark forest, reminiscent of creepy North American folklore that still gives chills.
The sk/nwalker (apparently it’s disrespectful to type its name? so i’ll respect it) is quite scary, it takes forms and pretends to be someone it’s not.
15points

#11

Figure in a red hoodie standing in a dark, creepy forest, reminiscent of North American folklore.
When we were kids my parents owned several cabins in Maine over the years and we always spent summers up there. My dad made up several great ghost stories that scared us.

One of our cabins was at the end Whispering Pine Drive up the road from Moose Pond. He made up a story about the moose man that stalked the woods around Moose Pond. It was a monster with a moose head that walked upright with razor sharp claws. When it was near, the wind in the pines would whisper your name before the moose man got you.

Dad made the best folklore to scare us kids while spending the weekend in the dark Maine woods.
13points

#12

North American blue lake and pine trees, reflecting the chills of folklore.
The stories of the simultaneous eruption of Mt. Shasta and Mt. Mazama, causing the mountain to collapse and form what later became Crater lake.

prettygirlarchive:

I think the most haunting part is that this isnt just some random ghost story, the landscape itself is still there as evidence of the event the story remembers
13points

Of course, not every legendary creature comes from the land. Some of the most terrifying ones are said to live beneath the waves. The Kraken, for example, comes from Scandinavian folklore and is often described as a gigantic sea monster that can drag entire ships into the ocean depths. Early stories described it as so enormous that sailors could mistake parts of its body for islands. While the real giant squid isn't exactly out there attacking ships, sightings of unusually large squids and octopuses may have helped inspire these frightening tales. For sailors facing the vast and mysterious ocean, it's easy to imagine how strange creatures appearing from the deep could eventually become stories about a monster powerful enough to swallow a ship whole.

#13

An old, dark building with 1875 inscribed, evoking the eerie atmosphere of North American folklore that gives chills.
Mothman. Shows up before disasters and nobody knows why.
12points

#14

Haunting image of bare trees emerging from misty water, a scene from chilling North American folklore.
Water babies, known to occupy Lake Tahoe and areas around the Great Basin and California. Small, beings or infants, sometimes featuring long dark hair, fishtails, or reptilian skin. Known for mimicking the sounds of a crying or laughing human baby to trick people into coming close to the water's edge. Once an unsuspecting person or child approaches or enters the water to help, the water babies drag them down to drown. Hearing or seeing them is often viewed as a serious omen of bad luck.
12points

#15

Dark, brooding mountains under heavy clouds, an atmospheric scene for North American folklore.
A few people have mentioned the appalachians, the mountains are so old and they have many stories associated with them.
The bell witch, old green eyes, the black eyed children, and Mothman are all pretty cool!
11points

Far from the cold Scandinavian seas, South African folklore tells of another enormous creature: the Grootslang. This legendary serpent is said to live deep inside a cave and, according to some stories, is as old as the Earth itself. The creature is often described as so large that it can devour elephants, while other versions of the legend claim it guards a hidden cavern filled with treasure and precious gems. Like many myths, the Grootslang may have been inspired by something very real—large African pythons, some of which can grow to impressive lengths. Of course, a 30-foot python is frightening enough without adding treasure, giant gems, and an ancient underground cave to the story!

#16

A woman is illuminated by the light of an open refrigerator, exploring North American folklore that still gives her chills.
North American house hippo. Imagine going for a midnight snack and you catch a house hippo in your pantry searching for potato chips.
10points

#17

My Mother’s stories of the holllows of Appalachian Kentucky. That place was haunted. Alva, Puckett Creek, Harlan County. Haunted by the Native Americans, and coal miners. My advice to you, don’t worry about the Native American staring in your window at night. He’s the least of your problems.
10points

#18

Foggy train tracks winding through a bare forest, creating a chilling North American folklore atmosphere.
Didn't see anyone mention the Gurdon Lights. Reports go back since the 1930's of a bobbing ghost light near abandoned train tracks. Lore is that it's a brakeman who was accidentally beheaded and is now looking for his head.

There's also the Creature of Boggy Creek, also known as the Fouke Monster. The earliest report of a sighting was in 1851 in the Memphis Enquirer. The first movie was made in 1972 (with four sequels), and since 2013 there's been a festival dedicated to it, with proceeds going to the local school district.

The White River has the White River Monster and even has the White River Monster Refuge(WRM Refuge) that was passed by the Senate in 1973 and sponsored by Senator Bob Harvey. The WRM refuge is located between two points. The southern point is known as the Old Grand Glaize, and the northern point is known as Rosie. It is illegal to hurt the White River Monster in this refuge. Sightings of the White River Monster, known as Whitey, began back in 1915 near Newport, and they are loved by the locals. People hypothesize that Whitey is anything from an alligator gar to an elephant seal.
10points

Japan has its own famous water-dwelling creature: the kappa. In Japanese folklore, kappa are supernatural beings often associated with rivers, ponds, and lakes. They are usually depicted with a mix of human, monkey, reptilian, and turtle-like features, including a shell and a dish-like indentation on their heads that holds water. According to traditional stories, this water is the source of their supernatural strength. Fortunately for anyone who happens to meet one, folklore also provides a clever way to defeat a kappa: trick it into bowing. Because the creature is said to be extremely polite, it may return the bow, spilling the water from its head and losing its power. It's a wonderfully strange example of how even terrifying mythical creatures can come with surprisingly specific weaknesses.

#19

A person stands in a misty, dark forest with a car's headlights shining, creating a creepy scene from North American folklore.
Maybe not scary but kind of sad.

The Anson lights, just outside of Abilene, Texas

Legend has it there was a small family living out there, and the mother would tell her children that when they were out playing past dark to keep an eye out for when they saw her lantern flashing and to flash theirs back, and to come home.

One night, her children didnt come home.

Allegedly her ghost is out there. If you park your car at the edge of the trees and flash your lights, you might see her flash hers back.
10points

#20

A car drives through a snow-covered, dark forest at night, suggesting chilling North American folklore.
I'm Californian so I'll go with two from here:

The dark watchers- indigenous legend of massive shadow figures seen in the mountains 

Char man of Ojai- said to be the spirit of a deceased firefighter you'll see a charred corpse running after your car at night.
9points
37
11