"Most Litigants Would Prefer Not to Have Their Medical Problems Published in the Public Records" But that’s not adequate reason to allow them to litigate pseudonymously, a district court rules. Reason · Jan 15, 2024
"Pseudonymity Is Unavailable" When "Plaintiffs Seek to Gag Sexual Assault Accusers" From Levy v. Shuster (né Doe v. Roe), handed down Nov. 28 but just unsealed yesterday, following the expiration of plaintiff's time to appeal: Background. According to the allegations in the First Amended Complaint and Jury Demand …, Plaintiff and Defendant dated for nearly a year while enrolled at Tulane… Reason · Jan 4, 2024
OK for Law School to Consider Whether "Students Possess the Mental and Emotional Stability to Join the Bar" "[T]he wide-ranging conspiracy Doe posits, one that tormented an ordinary law student for months on end using actors, poison, and a weapon that can send electricity wirelessly through brick walls, is too far beyond the pale of human experience to credit without supporting evidence, of which Doe has provided none." Reason · Dec 13, 2023
Court Rejects Attempt to Block Media from Reporting Name of Pseudonymous Litigant The court required the university defendants to keep plaintiff's identity confidential (common in pseudonymous Title IX cases), but refused to extend this to media, students, and others. Reason · Dec 4, 2023
Getting Dartmouth to Revoke Plaintiff's Admission Wasn't Speech on Issue of Public Interest, under California's "anti-SLAPP" statute (which allows for prompt dismissal of claims brought based on certain kinds of speech). Reason · Nov 30, 2023
The Best Plot Twists In Movies When there's a movie, there's sometimes a twist that blows your mind. Let's talk about eighteen that have blown mine. Cinemablend · Nov 28, 2023
No Pseudonymity in Disability Discrimination / Forced Labor Claim by Terrorism Expert Against Middlebury College From D.C. Superior Court Judge Todd Edelman's decision two weeks ago in Doe v. President & Fellows of Middlebury College: Plaintiff brought this lawsuit against numerous defendants [including American University, George Washington University, and Middlebury College -EV] alleging inter alia employment discrimination, harassment, forced labor, trafficking in labor or commercial… Reason · Nov 1, 2023
No Pseudonymity or Sealing for Japanese User Seeking to Use American Courts to Subpoena Twitter Critics' Names "Applicant's warning of a prima facie violation of Japanese law's privacy protections fails to constitute a harm severe enough" to justify pseudonymity. Reason · Aug 25, 2023
Why We Should Care About Pseudonymity in Litigation Like other features of legal procedure—such as the jury trial, the mechanism for appointing judges, the availability of appeal—pseudonymity both deeply affects the fairness of litigation and, often, the substantive outcomes. Reason · Aug 23, 2023
Can Plaintiffs Alleging Rape Sue Pseudonymously? The question remains unsettled, with lots of courts decisions on both sides. Reason · Aug 22, 2023
No Pseudonymity in Psychological Disability Employment Discrimination Lawsuit From Doe v. N.Y. City Dep't of Ed., decided today by Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil (S.D.N.Y.): This is an employment discrimination case. Plaintiff has worked for the DOE since 2012. Plaintiff alleges that she is "psychologically disabled" and was subjected to discrimination, harassment, and unlawful retaliation at work…. [Plaintiff] contends… Reason · Aug 15, 2023
Tattoos, gingerbread and baby onesies: Australians gripped by Matildas fever The Women’s World Cup co-hosts’ team has captured public imagination – from ardent fans to those who’ve never shown an interest in sport The Guardian - AU · Aug 10, 2023
ABA House of Delegates Adopts Resolution Opposing Single-Judge Divisions (Updated) Long before Judges Kacsmaryk and Tipton, there was Judge William Wayne Justice. Reason · Aug 10, 2023
Justice Barrett's Shadow Docket Policy: Do The Opposite Of Whatever The Fifth Circuit Did (Updated) Forget Doe v. Mills. Justice Barrett will grant relief on the shadow docket when the Fifth Circuit steps out of line. Reason · Aug 9, 2023
Reason · Aug 2, 2023 Unusual Denial of Pseudonymity to Plaintiff Suing Over Alleged Anti-Trans Discrimination Courts are generally inclined to allow litigants to remain pseudonymous to conceal their being transgender (see The Law of Pseudonymous Litigation, p. 1406); but they are also inclined to deny pseudonymity once the plaintiff had already identified himself or herself, and this is what made the difference in yesterday's decision…
Reason · Jul 20, 2023 No Pseudonymity in Lawsuit by Employees Alleging Sexual Harassment by Casino Magnate Steve Wynn From Doe v. Wynn Resorts Ltd., decided Monday by Magistrate Judge Cam Ferenbach (D. Nev.): Plaintiff Judy Does work at the Wynn/Encore Salon, and they claim that their employer allowed Steve Wynn to sexually harass them. In their ninety-two page third amended complaint, the Judy Does bring claims against Wynn…
Reason · Jul 18, 2023 No Pseudonymity for #TheyLied Plaintiff Suing for Libel and Invasion of Privacy Over Rape Accusations From Judge Nina Wang yesterday in Doe v. Roe (D. Colo.); note that I filed an objection to plaintiff's motion for pseudonymity: According to the allegations in the Complaint …, Plaintiff and Defendant dated for nearly a year while enrolled at Tulane University …. After their relationship ended in October…
Reason · Jul 6, 2023 Us Weekly Allegedly Used Married Woman's Photo as Picture of Mother of Elon Musk's Twins; Can She Sue for libel as a Jane Doe?
Reason · Jul 5, 2023 10th Cir. Narrowly Reads "Injury Litigated Against Would Be Incurred" Basis for Pseudonymous Litigation The court concludes that this justification doesn't generally let plaintiffs sue pseudonymously in libel or disclosure of private facts that seek damages.
Reason · Jun 29, 2023 Florida Cop Jails Toddler Son for Poopy Pants Plus: Snapchat cleared in sex crime case, New Hampshire embraces universal licensing reciprocity, and more...
Reason · Jun 7, 2023 Privacy Lawsuit Over Netflix's Our Father Fertility Fraud Documentary Can Go Forward "Dr. Cline inseminated many of his female patients with his own semen, ultimately, fathering approximately [94] children"; Netflix allegedly promised the Secret Children anonymity when making its film, but allegedly broke its promise.
Reason · Jun 6, 2023 Court Blocks Florida Law Limiting "Puberty Blockers" and Cross-Sex Hormones for Minors From Doe v. Ladapo, decided today by Judge Robert Hinkle (N.D. Fla.): This action presents a constitutional challenge to a Florida statute and rules that (1) prohibit transgender minors from receiving specific kinds of widely accepted medical care and (2) prohibit doctors from providing it. The treatments at issue are…
Reason · Jun 2, 2023 If Lawyer Forces Client to Have Sex, When Can Law Firm Be Liable for Negligent Supervision? "An attorney-client relationship between two adults does not present the same inherent danger or foreseeability" as "a relationship between an adult and a child in a religious organization."
Reason · Jun 1, 2023 First-Grade Teacher's "Pursu[ing] Her Own Transgender Agenda Outside the Curriculum" May Violate Constitutional Parental Rights Some excerpts from the long decision in Tatel v. Mt. Lebanon School Dist., decided yesterday by Judge Joy Flowers Conti (W.D. Pa.) (and see also the earlier decision in the case): This case involves the extent of parents' constitutional rights when a public school permits a teacher to inculcate the…
Reason · May 15, 2023 Florida Judge Argues That § 230 Is Beyond Congress's Power White v. Discovery Communications, LLC, decided Wednesday by the Florida Court of Appeal, rejected a man's libel claim against Netflix, on jurisdictional grounds (stemming in part from a particular procedural feature of the case), and against Microsoft on § 230 grounds. The facts are interesting, though largely beside the point…