A Bad Day at SCOTUS for Government Accountability The Supreme Court looks ready to further insulate rights-violating federal officers from facing civil liability. Reason · Nov 10
Switchblade Ban Violates Second Amendment, Fifth Circuit Holds From Knife Rights, Inc. v. Blanche, decided yesterday by Fifth Circuit Judge Jennifer Walker Elrod, joined by Judges Don Willett… The post Switchblade Ban Violates Second Amendment, Fifth Circuit Holds appeared first on Reason Magazine. Reason · Oct 22
"Trendy Eateries May Keep a Secret Menu; the United States Code Does Not" Some excerpts from the long opinion in R.J. Reynolds Tobacco v. FDA, written by Judge Don Willett and joined in… The post "Trendy Eateries May Keep a Secret Menu; the United States Code Does Not" appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Aug 19
Fifth Circuit Judges' Cert. Petition in Deray Mckesson Black Lives Matter Protest Liability Case From Fifth Circuit Judge Don Willett, joined by Judges Carl Stewart, James Graves, Stephen Higginson, Dana Douglas, and Irma Carrillo… The post Fifth Circuit Judges' Cert. Petition in Deray Mckesson Black Lives Matter Protest Liability Case appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Aug 1
Felon Gun Possession Bans, the Commerce Clause, and the Second Amendment In U.S. v. Williamson, Fifth Circuit Judges Jacques Wiener, Don Willett, and Cory Wilson followed Fifth Circuit precedent in holding… The post Felon Gun Possession Bans, the Commerce Clause, and the Second Amendment appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Mar 24
Man v. Nature Federal appellate courts are enacting an anti-environment agenda—especially in the ultraconservative 5th Circuit, new analysis shows. Texas Observer · Mar 16
Ilya Confusion At The Scalia Memorial Dinner Justice Barrett mentioned Ilya Somin, but meant Ilya Shapiro. Reason · Nov 7, 2025
No Qualified Immunity as to Allegations that Pre-K School Principal Failed to Respond to Sexual Molestation of Student by Teacher From Doe v. Jewell, decided Friday by Fifth Circuit Judge Patrick Higginbotham, joined by Judges Don Willett and James Ho:… The post No Qualified Immunity as to Allegations that Pre-K School Principal Failed to Respond to Sexual Molestation of Student by Teacher appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Aug 18, 2025
What Neil Gorsuch Gets Wrong About Judges and Government Power Plus: Ozzy Osbourne, RIP. Reason · Jul 24, 2025
On Remand, the 5th Circuit Again Blocks a Lawsuit by a Texas Reporter Arrested for Newsgathering Even if Laredo cops punished Priscilla Villarreal for constitutionally protected speech, the appeals court says, they would be protected by qualified immunity. Reason · Apr 9, 2025
5th Cir. Says More on When Federal Ban on Gun Possession by Drug Users Is Unconstitutional From Monday's U.S. v. Daniels decision, written by Fifth Circuit Judge Jerry Smith, joined by Judge Don Willett: Title 18… The post 5th Cir. Says More on When Federal Ban on Gun Possession by Drug Users Is Unconstitutional appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jan 8, 2025
Restriction on Veterinary Advice Given via Telemedicine Violates First Amendment From yesterday's decision in Hines v. Pardue, by Fifth Circuit Judge Don Willett, joined by Judges Cory Wilson: Dr. Ronald… The post Restriction on Veterinary Advice Given via Telemedicine Violates First Amendment appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Sep 27, 2024
Excessive Calls for Recusal Threaten Judicial Independence Activists and politicians look for almost any excuse to claim that judges should withdraw from cases. Their calls for recusal may be frivolous, but it gives them an opportunity to criticize judges they don't like. Reason · Jul 11, 2024
Can This Woman Sue the Rogue Prosecutor Who Allegedly Helped Upend Her Life? Prosecutor Ralph Petty was also employed as a law clerk—by the same judges he argued before. Reason · May 16, 2024
Reason · Apr 26, 2024 A Texas Reporter Busted for Asking Questions Asks SCOTUS To Reject the Criminalization of Journalism Priscilla Villarreal is appealing a 5th Circuit decision that dismissed her First Amendment lawsuit against Laredo police and prosecutors.
Reason · Apr 17, 2024 SCOTUS Misses a Chance To Protect Peaceful Protesters Under a legal theory endorsed by the 5th Circuit, Martin Luther King Jr. could have been liable for other people’s violence.
Reason · Apr 16, 2024 Can the Government Say: If You Want to Sell Us These Products, You Must Answer Our Questions About Them? From today's dissent from denial of rehearing en banc in Book People, Inc. v. Wong, written by Judge James Ho and joined by Jones, Smith, Duncan, and Engelhardt: States have a profound interest in protecting the innocence of children from various adult activities. We don't let children buy alcohol. We…
Reason · Feb 16, 2024 This Prosecutor Secretly Worked for the Judges Overseeing His Cases. Will His Victims Be Able To Sue? Ralph Petty likely violated the Constitution. In a rare move, a federal court signaled this week that lawsuits against him may not be dead on arrival.
Reason · Jan 30, 2024 She Was Arrested for Her Journalism. A Federal Court Says She Can't Sue. Priscilla Villarreal, also known as "Lagordiloca," has sparked a debate about free speech and who, exactly, is a journalist.
Reason · Dec 22, 2023 Trump's Promise to 'Indemnify' Cops 'Against Any and All Liability' Is Absurd for 2 Reasons Police officers already are routinely indemnified, and suing them for abuse is much harder than Trump claims.
Reason · Dec 18, 2023 5th Circuit Reluctantly Rules Against Victim of a Prosecutor Who Was Also a Law Clerk Ralph Petty's "conflicted dual-hat arrangement" as an advocate and an adjudicator was "utterly bonkers," Judge Don Willett notes.
Reason · Dec 2, 2023 Fifth Circuit Rules Against Texas in Case Where State Claimed Immigration and Drug Smuggling Qualify as "Invasion" The ruling is mostly based on statutory issues, but also covers the "invasion" question.
Chicago Sun-Times · Oct 12, 2023 Lawsuit against Black Lives Matter leader endangers free speech rights The U.S. Supreme Court should take the case of a Black Lives Matter leader in Louisiana who is being sued by a police officer who was injured in protests led by BLM.
Reason · Oct 11, 2023 Holding Protest Leaders Liable for Others' Violence Threatens First Amendment Rights A lawsuit against a Black Lives Matter activist could have a chilling impact on constitutionally protected activity.
Reason · Sep 26, 2023 Fifth Circuit Panel Reconsidering Part of Its Missouri v. Biden Decision [UPDATE: Don't blog when tired or in a hurry! I regret to say the original post erroneously said the Fifth Circuit granted rehearing en banc -- the panel just granted panel rehearing, and I've corrected the post accordingly. My apologies for the error.]