A Circuit Split Gives SCOTUS an Opportunity To Overturn a Federal Law That Makes Home Distilling a Felony The 6th Circuit upheld that 158-year-old law, while the 5th Circuit concluded it could not be justified as a revenue measure. Reason · May 13
Sixth Circuit Upholds Federal Law Banning Home Alcohol Distilleries, Creating a Circuit Split The decision is at odds with a recent ruling by the Fifth Circuit. Reason · Apr 22
‘La Gordiloca’ Lost at the Supreme Court but Won in Laredo The citizen-journalist and social media provocateur's case against local officials was thrown out in a decision that horrified First Amendment advocates. But, at home, observers say arresting her proved more trouble for the government than it was worth. Texas Observer · Apr 16
Fifth Circuit Strikes Down Federal Law Banning Home Alcohol Distilleries The ruling holds the law exceeds Congress' authority under the tax power and the Necessary and Proper Clause. But it does not consider the Commerce Clause. Reason · Apr 11
Arresting a Reporter for Asking Questions Was a 'Blatant First Amendment Violation,' Sonia Sotomayor Says The justice dissented from the Supreme Court's denial of a petition from a Texas journalist who was charged with felonies for practicing journalism. Reason · Mar 24
Fifth Circuit Comments on District Judge's Discussion of Using AI in Judicial Decisionmaking From La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, decided today by Judge Edith Jones, joined by Judge Kurt Engelhardt and… The post Fifth Circuit Comments on District Judge's Discussion of Using AI in Judicial Decisionmaking appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Feb 12
Rules of the Robe A sharp-eyed retiree uncovered evidence of judicial misconduct by the chief judge of Houston’s busy bankruptcy court. The unusual story highlights how other complaints against judges go ignored. Texas Observer · Jul 28, 2025
Why a Trump-Appointed Judge Is Torching His Own Court’s Qualified Immunity Logic—and the Government Abuse It Enables Judge James C. Ho recently described a troubling phenomenon on the 5th Circuit and the government abuse it enables. Reason · Jul 15, 2025
On Remand, the 5th Circuit Again Blocks a Lawsuit by a Texas Reporter Arrested for Newsgathering Even if Laredo cops punished Priscilla Villarreal for constitutionally protected speech, the appeals court says, they would be protected by qualified immunity. Reason · Apr 9, 2025
The 5th Circuit Says the Federal Ban on Handgun Sales to Young Adults Is Unconstitutional The government failed to persuade the appeals court that 18-to-20-year-olds are not part of "the people" or that the age restriction is consistent with the "historical tradition of firearm regulation." Reason · Jan 30, 2025
The Maga legal networks that could topple Planned Parenthood and gut women’s healthcare Revealed: outcome of coming election may determine staying power of hard-right activist Leonard Leo’s crusade to reshape US courts The Guardian - US · Oct 22, 2024
Citizen Journalist Barred From Press Conference Can Sue Texas Sheriff for Violating His Rights, Judge Rules The decision is a reminder that independent reporters are still protected by the same First Amendment as journalists in legacy media. Reason · Sep 27, 2024
A Texas Reporter Was Arrested for Asking Questions. The State Says That's No Big Deal. Opposing Priscilla Villarreal's petition for Supreme Court review, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton portrays basic journalism as "incitement." Reason · Sep 18, 2024
The Independent UK · Aug 1, 2024 Appeals court: Separate, distinct minority groups can't join together to claim vote dilution A divided federal appeals court has ruled that separate, distinct minority groups cannot join together in coalitions to claim their votes are diluted in redistricting cases under the federal Voting Rights Act
Reason · Jul 19, 2024 En Banc Fifth Circuit Upholds Mississippi Felon Disenfranchisement The full court rejects an Eighth Amendment challenge to a provision in the Mississippi Constitution.
Reason · Jul 18, 2024 Federal Appeals Court Upholds Mississippi's Jim Crow–Era Felon Voting Ban "In short, 'cruel and unusual' is not the same as 'harmful and unfair,'" the court wrote.
Reason · May 30, 2024 These Strange Bedfellows Want SCOTUS To Remind the 5th Circuit That Journalism Is Not a Crime An ideologically diverse mix of individuals and organizations supports a Texas journalist who was arrested for asking questions.
Reason · May 29, 2024 This Journalist Was Arrested, Strip-Searched, and Jailed for Filming Police. Will He Get Justice? Justin Pulliam's arrest and lawsuit once again demand we ask if "real" journalists are entitled to a different set of rights.
Reason · May 1, 2024 Journalism Is Not a Crime, Even When It Offends the Government Julian Assange and Priscilla Villarreal were both arrested for publishing information that government officials wanted to conceal.
Top News · Apr 6, 2024 Federal Appeals Court Blocks Biden Student Debt Relief Plan 5th U.S. Circuit Court deems Biden's student debt relief plan unlawful, sparking legal debate.
Reason · Feb 20, 2024 The Biden Administration Is Bent on Setting an Alarming Precedent by Prosecuting Julian Assange The WikiLeaks founder already has spent as much time in a London prison as DOJ lawyers say he is likely to serve if convicted in the U.S.
Reason · Jan 30, 2024 She Was Arrested for Her Journalism. A Federal Court Says She Can't Sue. Priscilla Villarreal, also known as "Lagordiloca," has sparked a debate about free speech and who, exactly, is a journalist.
Texas Observer · Jan 24, 2024 The Judges Who Ruled Against La Gordiloca Are Criminalizing Watchdog Journalism The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals threw out a lawsuit by Laredo’s most famous citizen journalist, Priscilla Villarreal, aka La Gordiloca.
Reason · Nov 20, 2023 No Liability for Supposed Medical Journal Article Misrepresentation About How to Treat Lyme Disease From the Fifth Circuit's decision Thursday in Torrey v. Infectious Diseases Soc'y of Am., written by Judge Kyle Duncan, joined by Judges Carl Stewart and Edith Jones; seems quite right to me: A professional society specializing in the study and treatment of infectious diseases published guidelines in a peer-reviewed medical…