Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Disparaging scientists, disappearing warrants, and disgruntled lawyers. Reason · Mar 31, 2023
Supreme Court Should Take and Reverse Fifth Circuit Decision that Creates a Catch-22 for Takings Claims Against State Government The badly flawed ruling defies the Supreme Court's landmark 2019 decision forbidding such Catch-22 traps. Reason · Mar 25, 2023
Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Anti-Muslim tweets, inactive warrants, and anti-Muslim prison guards. Reason · Mar 24, 2023
Fifth Circuit Again Stays FDA Denial of E-Cigarette Product Application Another opinion exposing the Food and Drug Administration's vaping problem. Reason · Mar 24, 2023
Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Herring monitors, state-created dangers, and kicking out the jams. Reason · Mar 17, 2023
Second Amendment Roundup: Should the Fifth Circuit Reconsider Rahimi En Banc? The Fifth Circuit's decision in United States v. Rahimi, which held that the federal statute prohibiting possession of a firearm by a person subject to a domestic violence restraining order violates the Second Amendment, has managed to stay in the news for longer than most circuit court decisions. On March… Reason · Mar 15, 2023
David Lat on the Stanford Law School Disruption of Speech by Fifth Circuit Judge Kyle Duncan David Lat's Original Jurisdiction newsletter has, as usual, excellent and detailed coverage. I started quoting but then realized that I couldn't excerpt it and still do the matter justice; and quoting the whole thing would be unfair to Lat as an author. I therefore very much encourage you to read… Reason · Mar 11, 2023
Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Speedy trials, political advertising, and horseracing. Reason · Mar 10, 2023
Department of Justice v. Texas Judges Does DOJ actually agree with "a couple of law professors beating a drum on Twitter"? Reason · Mar 4, 2023
Judge James Ho's Revised Concurrence in the Second Amendment / Restraining Order Case Yesterday, the Fifth Circuit released an updated version of its opinion in U.S. v. Rahimi, which held that people can't be disarmed just based on a civil restraining order. The changes to the majority are comparatively minor, but Judge Ho used the release of the new opinion as an occasion… Reason · Mar 3, 2023
An Unusual Supreme Court Split in Bittner v. United States The Bank Secrecy Act divides the justices in an unusual way, and Justice Barrett authors her fourth opinion in an argued case. Reason · Feb 28, 2023
Supreme Court to hear case that threatens existence of consumer protection agency At issue is how the CFPB is funded: It gets its money from the Federal Reserve, which in turn is funded by bank fees, and not through congressional appropriations. WEKU · Feb 27, 2023
Justice Kagan Double-Helixes Justices Gorsuch and Kavanaugh Kagan: "Kavanaugh, J. (recognizing that the argument may be forfeited, but opining on it anyway)." Reason · Feb 25, 2023
Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Boisterous school children, suspicious mispronunciations, and convicted misdemeanant Don Blankenship. Reason · Feb 24, 2023
Reason · Feb 24, 2023 Justice Kagan Affirms En Banc Fifth Circuit On Wednesday, the Supreme Court decided Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. v. Hewitt. The facts of the case are straightforward enough: does a "tool-pusher" who makes more than $200,000 per year, while working on an offshore oil rig, qualify for overtime pay? The law is, admittedly, complex. There is an…
Reason · Feb 24, 2023 Victims' Families File Petition in the Fifth Circuit Seeking to Enforce Rights in the Boeing Case The families argue that they should have been given an opportunity to confer with prosecutors under the Crime Victims' Rights Act before Boeing's deferred prosecution agreement was finalized.
Reason · Feb 22, 2023 Judge O'Connor Rules that the Boeing 737 MAX Crashes Victims' Families Cannot Enforce Their Right to Confer with Prosecutors While expressing great sympathy for the victims' families, Judge O'Connor concludes that no remedy is available for the Justice Department's failure to enforce the families' right to confer under the Crime Victims' Rights Act.
Reason · Feb 17, 2023 Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Dam removal, malicious prosecution, and pre-trial diversion.
Reason · Feb 13, 2023 Federalist Society Panel on "Discussion, Coercion, and the Pursuit of Truth" at Law Schools The panel was moderated by Fifth Circuit Judge James Ho, and included former Solicitor General Paul Clement, Prof. Renee Lettow Lerner, legal journalist David Lat, lawyer Jay Edelson, and me.
Salon · Feb 9, 2023 "Terrifying" court let abusers keep guns Advocates for domestic violence victims were stunned by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling
The Texas Tribune · Feb 9, 2023 Appeals court ruling says alleged domestic abusers have a constitutional right to keep their guns Advocates for domestic violence victims were stunned by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling, which continued a string of court decisions citing the Second Amendment to erase gun restrictions.
Salon · Feb 7, 2023 "Originalism" will likely kill women A federal court finds that women's lives are less important than a bizarre misreading of the Second Amendment
Reason · Feb 7, 2023 Are Circuit Court Decisions from Before 1892 Binding On The Circuit Courts of Appeals? The Evarts Act of 1892 established the modern-day circuit courts of appeals.
Reason · Feb 7, 2023 Abortion and the 13th Amendment Judges cannot take the Supreme Court's silence as a ground to subvert Supreme Court precedent.
Reason · Feb 3, 2023 Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Alaskan Natives, Alaska Airlines, and Alaskan students.