Will Massachusetts v. EPA get the Lemon v. Kurtzman quiet interment? The landmark environmental decision may have already been abandoned. Reason · Jun 26, 2023
Justice Kavanaugh's Arrested Development U.S. v. Texas, Linda v. Richard, and Brett v. Amy. Reason · Jun 26, 2023
Counting to Five in Texas v. United States Justice Kavanaugh penned a narrow decision that cobbled together a majority. Reason · Jun 25, 2023
Predicting Case Authors and Outcomes as the Supreme Court Hits the Home Stretch Some worth-what-you-paid-for-them predictions for the final(?) week of SCOTUS opinions. Reason · Jun 25, 2023
"Brackeen's Third Sovereign" I much appreciated the guest-post by Prof. Lorianne Updike Toler (Northern Illinois) on Brackeen back in November, based on her recent University of Chicago Law Review article, The Missing Indian Affairs Clause; now that Brackeen has been handed down, I thought I'd pass along this follow-up: Halaand v. Brackeen, which… Reason · Jun 24, 2023
Making Sense of Arizona v. Navajo Nation Justice Gorsuch's conservative colleagues now ignore him in Indian cases. Reason · Jun 23, 2023
Roaming Polansky and the Constitutionality of Qui Tam Three decades later, the George H.W. Bush SCOTUS strategy finally has three votes. Reason · Jun 20, 2023
Reservations For Two Justices Gorsuch and Alito have diametrically opposite perspectives on Indian Tribes Reason · Jun 18, 2023
Professor Barrett Flunks Brackeen's Lawyers Justice Thomas would place the burden on the government, and follow a presumption of liberty. Reason · Jun 17, 2023
Congratulations to Randy Barnett and Sam Bray, on Their S. Ct. Cites Randy Barnett's The Original Meaning of the Commerce Clause was cited on Thursday by Justice Thomas's dissent in Haaland v. Brackeen and on May 25 in Justice Thomas's concurrence in Sackett v. EPA, and Sam Bray's "Necessary and Proper" and "Cruel and Unusual": Hendiadys in the Constitution was cited on… Reason · Jun 17, 2023
Download Edited Version Of Haaland v. Brackeen From Barnett/Blackman Supplement 133 pages down to 30 pages. Reason · Jun 17, 2023
SCOTUS Covers The Waterfront On The Lake Of Torches He coulda been a contender. Reason · Jun 16, 2023
Justice Thomas's Dissent in Health and Hospital Corp. of Marion County v. Talevski A thorough originalist analysis of the "so-called Spending Clause" that casts Thiboutout in doubt. Reason · Jun 8, 2023
Salon · May 27, 2023 SCOTUS is helping polluters Brett Kavanaugh broke from the conservative majority to warn about helping businesses pollute the water
Reason · May 25, 2023 In Sackett v. EPA, the Supreme Court Cuts Back Federal Regulatory Authority Over Wetlands The Clean Water Act decision was a unanimous win for the Sacketts, and a 5-4 victory for Justice Scalia's 2006 Rapanos v. United States plurality.
Reason · May 19, 2023 Sotomayor and Kagan "Go Back To School" Each Other in Warhol v. Goldsmith Does The Relationship Between Justices Sotomayor and Kagan "Have Much Of A Future"? Or was this just their "Fifteen Minutes" of Flame Wars?
Reason · May 18, 2023 Justice Gorsuch on COVID-19 and Emergency Government Arizona v. Mayorkas is one of the cases dealing with "Title 42 orders" that "severely restricted immigration to this country for the ostensible purpose of preventing the spread of COVID–19"; today, the court issued a procedural order in the case, and Justice Gorsuch wrote a statement regarding that decision. It…
Reason · May 16, 2023 Another Voting Paradox Case (Pork Division) The California Pork case (NPCC v. Ross) is another example of a case whose outcome conflicts with the doctrines adopted by the Court itself in its opinions.
Reason · May 12, 2023 How Did Justice Gorsuch Lose A Majority In National Pork Producers? Thomas assigned the majority to Justice Gorsuch, but he couldn't hold five all the way.
Reason · May 12, 2023 The Territoriality Principle Without a Clause A brief comment on National Pork Producers v. Ross
Reason · May 11, 2023 SCOTUS Chooses California Over Pork Producers and Bacon Consumers (and Issues Four Other Opinions Too) The Supreme Court issues five merits opinions, but there are still forty more waiting.
Reason · May 1, 2023 Chevron Matters — But Not as Much as You Might Think Overruling Chevron won't gut the administrative state or even severely constrain it. But it could help strengthen the rule of law.
Reason · Apr 30, 2023 The New York Times Uncovered The Worst-Kept Secret In Academia Summer study-abroad programs are cushy vacations for students and boondoggles to attract elite faculty.
Reason · Apr 27, 2023 Oral Argument Indicates Property Rights Likely to Prevail in Supreme Court Home Equity Theft Takings Case The decision may even be unanimous.