Giuliani Admits His Oft-Told Tale of Georgia Election Fraud Was Not True Unlike calling Trump's stolen-election fantasy "the Big Lie," his lawyer's statements were demonstrably false assertions of fact. Reason · Jul 31, 2023
Accusing Trump of Perpetrating "Big Lie" Is Opinion and Therefore Not Libelous, Court Holds From Trump v. CNN, decided Friday (quite correctly, I think) by Judge Raag Singhal (S.D. Fla.): Trump alleges that CNN defamed him by making statements comparing him to Hitler and the Nazi regime …: [a.] On January 25, 2021, CNN published an article written by Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a "frequent contributor… Reason · Jul 31, 2023
Court Rejects Attempt to Expurgate Racial Slur in Complaint Alleging Racial Slur From Sharper v. Right Away Maintenance Co., decided yesterday by Magistrate Judge Scott D. Johnson (M.D. La.): Plaintiff began this litigation pro se on August 16, 2022, drafting and filing his original Complaint without the assistance of counsel. However, Plaintiff recently retained an attorney, who enrolled in May of 2023.… Reason · Jul 27, 2023
Can Plaintiff Who Lost a Case Get Retroactively Pseudonymized, Because of Fear of Employment Consequences? Two Central District of California case reach different results. Reason · Jul 26, 2023
Slurs When Discussing Rap, Duty of Fair Representation, and Union's Attempt to "Balance the Racial Sensitivities" From Magistrate Judge Stewart Aaron's Report and Recommendation today in Kelly v. Comm. Workers of Am. (S.D.N.Y.), the factual allegations (assumed to be true for purposes of the motion to dismiss, though of course there hasn't been any finding yet about what the facts actually were): Plaintiff, a Caucasian male,… Reason · Jul 25, 2023
First Amendment Claim of Professor Fired Over Article Claiming Race-Based Genetic IQ Differences … can go forward, rules a federal judge, denying Cleveland State University's motion to dismiss. Reason · Jul 18, 2023
No Pseudonymity for #TheyLied Plaintiff Suing for Libel and Invasion of Privacy Over Rape Accusations From Judge Nina Wang yesterday in Doe v. Roe (D. Colo.); note that I filed an objection to plaintiff's motion for pseudonymity: According to the allegations in the Complaint …, Plaintiff and Defendant dated for nearly a year while enrolled at Tulane University …. After their relationship ended in October… Reason · Jul 18, 2023
Former NYPD Commissioner Bernard Kerik accused of strong-arming man over defective PPE lawsuit NEW YORK — Former NYPD Commissioner Bernard Kerik tried to strong-arm a Staten Island man who is suing a personal protection equipment company, intimidating the plaintiff and his associates to discourage him from going public about his complaints, according to court documents. Tribune News Service · Jul 6, 2023
Alleged Panama Papers Leaker Allowed to Proceed Pseudonymously in Breach of Contract Lawsuit Against Germany But the court insisted that the alleged leaker file identifying information under seal with the court, notwithstanding the alleged leaker's claim that the court computers could be hacked. Reason · Jul 3, 2023
North Carolina House speaker accused of trading group sex for political favours ‘Our marriage was a nightmare, and since I left him it has gotten worse. We are reaching the end of our divorce process and this is how he’s lashing out,’ wife says The Independent UK · Jun 20, 2023
No Pseudonymity for Plaintiff in Medical Data Breach Case "[A]n individual's name is not sensitive data in and of itself, and Plaintiff does not explain how publication of Plaintiff's name would place Plaintiff's data at further risk." Reason · Jun 9, 2023
DJ Paul Oakenfold accused of sexual harassment by former assistant The DJ, who denies the claims and describes them as baseless, is accused of masturbating in front of the PA, in incidents of increasing severity The Guardian - UK · Jun 5, 2023
First-Grade Teacher's "Pursu[ing] Her Own Transgender Agenda Outside the Curriculum" May Violate Constitutional Parental Rights Some excerpts from the long decision in Tatel v. Mt. Lebanon School Dist., decided yesterday by Judge Joy Flowers Conti (W.D. Pa.) (and see also the earlier decision in the case): This case involves the extent of parents' constitutional rights when a public school permits a teacher to inculcate the… Reason · Jun 1, 2023
No Pseudonymity in Lawsuit Alleging Virginia Military Institute Hazing From Anonymous v. Bennett, decided May 3 by Roanoke County Judge Charles Dorsey: Virginia Code section 8.01-15.1 permits a Plaintiff to proceed anonymously under a pseudonym "if the anonymous litigant discharges the burden of showing special circumstances such that the need for anonymity outweighs the public's interest in knowing the… Reason · May 30, 2023
Reason · May 23, 2023 Kicking Out Paid Conference Attendee May Be Breach of Contract—but His Returning Is Still Criminal Trespass A case stemming from a "Holocaust revisionist's" expulsion from a conference on "Mennonites and the Holocaust."
Reason · May 2, 2023 Lawsuit: Police Officer Broke a 61-Year-Old Woman's Leg, Then Bragged He 'Man-Dropped' Her Before assaulting her, the cops taunted her for being homeless, she claims.
Reason · Mar 28, 2023 No Pseudonymity for Plaintiff in Lawsuit That Would Further Publicize His Criminal History From Doe v. HireRight LLC, decided yesterday by Judge Stephen McNamee (D. Ariz.): Four years ago, Plaintiff was charged with two felonies. As part of a plea agreement, he pled guilty to both charges in exchange for one of the charges being downgraded to a misdemeanor. Thus, he was convicted…
Reason · Mar 28, 2023 Title IX Sexual Assault Cases and Extraterritoriality From today's decision by Judge Paul Maloney (W.D. Mich.) in Doe v. Calvin Univ.: In 2020, Plaintiff Jane Doe attended Calvin University in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Calvin University offered a study abroad program in the Philippines with Silliman University, a private university in Dumaguete, Philippines. Silliman University selected some of…
Reason · Mar 23, 2023 No Pseudonymity in Student's Claim That She Was Wrongly Found to Have Cheated From Doe v. Univ. of Penn., decided today by Judge Cynthia Rufe (E.D. Pa.): At all times relevant to this action, Plaintiff was a student in Penn's Pre-Med Post- Baccalaureate Program …. Plaintiff began the Program in May 2020, and had planned to apply to medical school upon its completion…
Reason · Mar 23, 2023 No Temporary Restraining Order Against Critic of Israeli Muslim Institution, who allegedly accused it of being an agent of the Israeli government and "refer[red] to individuals associated with the Academy as pigs and use[d] porcine imagery to insult those individuals."
Reason · Mar 16, 2023 "The Duration of This Divorce Action and Post-Judgment Proceedings Is Approaching the Quarter Century Mark" From New York trial judge Ariel Chesler's opinion last month in Z.U. v. F.U., just the introduction: The duration of this divorce action and post-judgment proceedings is approaching the quarter century mark. But, neither that length of time nor the fact that this is the 50th motion sequence fully captures…
Reason · Mar 14, 2023 "Plaintiff Alleges He Fronted Howell Drugs in Exchange for a Promise to Pay Plaintiff Within the Week" From McElrath v. MetaQuest, decided Friday by Magistrate Judge Kaymani West (D.S.C.): Plaintiff alleges he fronted Howell drugs in exchange for a promise to pay Plaintiff within the week. Plaintiff claims he and Howell agreed that Plaintiff would be allowed to confiscate Howell's enclosed trailer if Howell failed to pay.…
Reason · Mar 6, 2023 Police Officer's Defamation Suit Over Claims That Circled-Finger Sign Was "White Supremacist" Dismissed There's finally a substantive decision in Olthaus v. Niesen, the case in which I argued before the Ohio Supreme Court challenging a pretrial prior restraint on defendant's publishing plaintiff's name, and in which my invaluable pro bono counsel Jeffrey M. Nye (Stagnaro, Saba & Patterson) argued on my behalf challenging…
Reason · Feb 22, 2023 Libel Suit by Gen. Michael Flynn's Sister Against CNN Dismissed I'm too slammed today to comment in detail on it, but I just thought I'd note the decision handed down today by Judge Mary Scriven (M.D. Fla.) in Valerie Flynn v. CNN: Plaintiff, a citizen of Florida, is a private individual and sister to Retired General Michael Flynn. Plaintiff's suit…
Reason · Feb 17, 2023 Private College Coaches' Flexibility to Eject Team Members Based on Condemnation by Teammates "Coaches must generally consider a variety of factors—both objective and subjective—in managing a team, and these factors include concerns about distractions, team cohesion, and morale."