First Circuit Declines to Mandate Religious Exemptions from Public School Vaccination Requirement, at least on an emergency basis while an appeal on the subject is pending. Reason · Nov 5
Interesting Dissent in American Indian Religious Case Under Texas RFRA From a dissent from rehearing en banc Friday in Perez v. City of San Antonio, by Fifth Circuit Judge Andrew… The post Interesting Dissent in American Indian Religious Case Under Texas RFRA appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Mar 4
California Policy Limiting Teachers' Disclosure to Parents of Student's Changed Gender Identity Violates First Amendment, Court Holds The introduction to today's long opinion by Judge Roger Benitez in Mirabelli v. Olson (S.D. Cal.): Long before Horace Mann… The post California Policy Limiting Teachers' Disclosure to Parents of Student's Changed Gender Identity Violates First Amendment, Court Holds appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Dec 23, 2025
Chief Justice Burger Set the Stage for the Originalist Revolution While conservative criticisms of the Burger Court may be justified, those criticisms do not apply to the "The Chief." He had only one vote on the Court ... and, too often, too little support from his colleagues to reach originalist results. Reason · Oct 6, 2025
The First Amendment and Restrictions on Gathering Information by Drone From Sixth Circuit Judge John Bush's very interesting opinion Friday respecting denial of rehearing en banc in Yoder v. Bowen:… The post The First Amendment and Restrictions on Gathering Information by Drone appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Oct 6, 2025
Justice Thomas Avoids Substantive Due Process with Meyer and Pierce Thomas may attempt to recast Pierce as a Free Exercise case, but it cannot be understood in that fashion. Reason · Jul 9, 2025
The Status of Smith and Yoder After Mahmoud The Court continues avoiding the Smith issue, but in an unexpected way. Reason · Jul 9, 2025
Contrasting Coercion for the Free Exercise Clause in Mahmoud and Coercion for the Establishment Clause in Kennedy The Court finds that the government cannot indirectly coerce children who are exercising their religious beliefs, but the government can indirectly coerce children who are not exercising their religious beliefs. Reason · Jul 9, 2025
In LGBTQ+ storybook case, Supreme Court handed a win to parental rights, raising tough questions for educators The Supreme Court tends to save its blockbuster orders for the last day of the term – and 2025 was no exception. The Conversation · Jul 1, 2025
School Choice Could Fix the Conflicts That Led to the Supreme Court's Mahmoud Decision There’s no need to fight over lessons if you’re not forced to learn in government-run battlegrounds. Reason · Jun 30, 2025
Free Exercise Clause Rights to Opt Children Out of Public School Lesson That "Substantially Interfer[e]" with Their Children's "Religious Development" [1.] The Supreme Court has been debating the meaning of the Free Exercise Clause for over 60 years. One view… The post Free Exercise Clause Rights to Opt Children Out of Public School Lesson That "Substantially Interfer[e]" with Their Children's "Religious Development" appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jun 28, 2025
100 years ago, the Supreme Court made a landmark ruling on parents’ rights in education – today, another case raises new questions A century ago, the Supreme Court handed down one of its most important cases about education. On June 1, 1925, the court struck down an Oregon statute requiring all students to attend public school – a law critics argued was meant to limit faith-based schools, at a time when anti-Catholic… The Conversation · Jun 5, 2025
Justices Gorsuch and Thomas Dissent from Court's Declining to Hear Apache Religious Freedom Case From today's dissent from denial of certiorari by Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justice Thomas, in Apache Stronghold v. U.S.: For… The post Justices Gorsuch and Thomas Dissent from Court's Declining to Hear Apache Religious Freedom Case appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · May 27, 2025
Reason · Mar 4, 2025 Court OK's N.Y. Repeal of Religious Exemptions from Vaccination Requirement An excerpt from the Second Circuit's long (and, I think, generally correct) decision yesterday in Miller v. McDonald (Judges José… The post Court OK's N.Y. Repeal of Religious Exemptions from Vaccination Requirement appeared first on Reason.com.
Reason · Nov 19, 2024 Part XII: The Free Exercise of Religion An Introduction To Constitutional Law Video Library: Sherbert v. Verner (1963), Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972), Employment Division v. Smith (1990), Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah (1993), Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores (2014)
Reason · Aug 26, 2022 Protecting People from Their Own Religious Communities: Judicial Evaluation of a Religious Community's Qualities This new article of mine will be coming out next year in the Journal of Law and Religion, and I thought I'd serialize it here; there's still plenty of time for editing, so I'd love to hear people's feedback. Here's Part III (Part II is more doctrinal, so I'm skipping…